Stalled 179 Ludlow “Rat Castle” Approved for Completion

Posted on: November 8th, 2011 at 6:09 am by

For the second time in as many weeks, another notoriously stalled Lower East Side development is getting the proverbial new lease on life. Last month, it was Hotel Ludlow that was scooped up by BD Hotels (Maritime, Jane Hotels); today it’s the infamous “Rat Castle” across the street at 179 Ludlow.

Yesterday evening, the Community Board 3 Land-Use Subcommittee met to discuss the fate of this five-year-old neighborhood eyesore. But before we jump in, a quick history recap.  179 Ludlow was initially started by 2 Funny Guys in March 2006; bankruptcy followed three months later; first-timer Michelangelo Russo then took the reigns for $5.2 million but quickly followed in the footsteps of failure.  Turns out, Russo entered the fray with capital funded by Michael Goldberg who makes a career of bailing out busted projects and turning them.  Foreclosure followed in March 2010, and as we all know, shit rolls downhill. Now the lender is stuck holding the hot potato, so to speak.

Goldberg appeared before the board to gain approval to finally complete 179 Ludlow Street. His goal is two floors of commercial use totaling 2,880 square-feet, and five 2-BR condo units up above.  The argument was pretty much a slam-dunk case considering the entity, ER Holdings LLC, met three necessary criteria set forth by the Board of Standards and Appeals:

  • A significant amount of work done on the building – 70% of the project was complete before the 2008 rezoning from C-61 to C44A was passed.
  • A significant amount of money invested – $7.5 million was put into the development
  • Investors face financial loss if the application is not approved – it would cost more money to enforce zoning compliance and dismantle the seventh floor ($2 million).

Members were a bit weary, concerned about a possible bait-and-switch with the ground and first level commercial space. There were worries about having a monster club moving in here. And that the real estate should be considered for “community use.” Goldberg insisted that he would only want higher-end gym tenants like SoulCycle to move in here (he’s meeting with them next week to discuss).

Despite the wee bit of static, the issue sailed through the approval process. The board supported the measure to complete 179 Ludlow (15 Yes, 2 No, 1 abstain, 1 present no vote).

Recent Stories

Elizabeth Street Garden will be Bulldozed and Redeveloped by Penrose Development

Now that election season is over, there is finally movement toward the controversial destruction and redevelopment of the Elizabeth Street Garden. The city will apparently announce today that it’s chosen the developer to carry out this task. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development awarded the contract for the seven-story project to Penrose Development. The […]

Do Big Belly Trash Compacting Bins Contribute to Litter Problem?

This photo says it all, really. Namely that those Big Belly receptacles might not actually be working to plan. The multi-thousand-dollar trash bins began appearing across the streets of Chinatown and the Lower East Side earlier this fall, but are they helping or just part of the problem? Despite the best of intentions, an overflowing Big […]

Open 3 Months, ‘Brigitte’ Seeks Basement Club on Ludlow

Of course this would happen. Open nigh on three months, Canal Street bistro Brigitte is already angling to open a basement club. Naturally. Ownership this week submitted a dressed-up application to alter its liquor license to include bar and seats in the cellar. Blueprints show communal table seating to accommodate twenty-four additional patrons, plus a […]

Hill & Dale Partners with ‘Thai Direct Bowls’ on Allen Street

Hill & Dale is now open for takeaway Thai lunch options. The Allen Street watering hole last month struck a partnership with Thai Direct Bowls, a startup that offers “authentic meal kits, healthy lunch bowls and delicious food products.” It’s sub-leasing the space from the golden-age-of-radio-themed bar during daytime hours (until 4pm). Patrons can choose […]

8-Story Commercial Development Planned for Chinatown ‘Diamond Center’ on the Bowery

The Chinatown diamond district is getting cut once again. It wasn’t enough that the Diamond Corner at Hester Street and the Bowery was sacked and replaced with a Bank of America branch. 76 Bowery is coming down, too. And like its neighbor one door to the north, it’ll be redeveloped into an eight-story commercial building. […]