Former Residents of 289 Grand Street Sue Landlord for “Gross Negligence”

Posted on: February 23rd, 2012 at 6:43 am by

Nearly two years after a devastating seven-alarm fire tore through a bustling block of Lower East Side, killing one and leaving 200 homeless, the complicated saga of 289 Grand Street continues. Displaced residents from the corner building have been engaged in legal matters since the blaze forced them from home. Most recent was a case in August 2011 which accused the landlords of negligence. Through it all the building residents are trying to stop demolition, saying it can be saved.

289 Grand Street, morning after fire (April 2010)

Now another lawsuit is underway. Last week, the twenty-two former tenants filed suit against the owners and former managers of the property – Fair Only Real Estate Corporation, Fair Only Realty, Solomon Scheinfeld, Ralph Sherman, Wong’s Grand Street Realty, Tong’s Realty, Tong’s Management, and Tong’s Management Corp. The nineteen-page complaint reveals the terrible conditions that plaintiffs allege led to the fire, and the lack of preventative action by landlords. Some excerpts:

Years of willful neglect by the 283-285 landlords created a tinderbox that enabled the fire to spread rapidly through open voids and light shafts. Among other things, the 283-285 landlords negligently maintained 283 Grand Street’s electrical wiring, leaving wiring exposed throughout the building and thus increasing the likelihood of an electrical malfunction.

The 283-285 landlords kept 283-285 Grand Street in a perpetual state of disrepair, allowing severe water leaks to rot out walls and invade electrical outlets. Throughout the buildings, the 283-285 landlords provided ample kindling for the fire, failing to remove garbage and rubbish, which routinely spilled out into shared hallways and stairwells and accumulated in the buildings’ basements and backyards.

Both 283 and 285 Grand Street are classified as old law tenements under the New York City Administrative Code. Although required by Sections 27-2005 and 28-301.1 of the New York City Administrative Code and Section 15-07 of the New York City Rules, the 283-285 landlords had not installed or maintained proper fire stopping in the walls, hallways, stairs, and other building partitions of 283 and 285 Grand Street. The 283-285 landlords also failed to patch holes in the walls and ceilings, leaving exposed wooden slats. The lack of any insulation or other fire stopping material allowed the fire to rapidly travel up the buildings’ walls, spreading to the upper floors of the adjoining 289 Grand Street.

Plaintiffs are seeking punitive damages for gross negligence. Or, the contractual language, “recovery for the 283-285 Grand Street Landlord’s intentional, willful, malicious, and negligent actions, which directly caused the Fire at 283 and 285 Grand Street, destroyed their personal property, and left them temporarily homeless.”

For more on the case, consult the legal paperwork below:

289 Grand Street Lawsuit

Recent Stories

Photo: NYC Municipal Archives
On the Ground 7 Years Before the Essex Street Market Became a Reality [PHOTOS]

In the coming years, each of the Essex Street Market buildings will fall to accommodate the new Essex Crossing mega-project. The facility was built seventy-five years ago to move the plethora of pushcarts indoors. The archival photo is dated sometime in 1933, seven years before the one-story commercial buildings were constructed by order of Mayor LaGuardia. […]

Photo: Lori Greenberg
DayLife Presents ‘Lower EAT Side’ Sunday June 14

DayLife is once again kicking off the summer season with its annual outdoor LES celebration. This year’s event, sponsored by ConEd and G-Shock, is being called “Lower EAT Side.” We see what you did there. It may be a far cry from the Orchard Street pushcarts of yesteryear, but the Lower East Side BID and its semi-regular […]

Photo: Catjia Rehkamp
This Lower East Side Photographer Spent a Year Chronicling Local Can Collectors

Roughly nine years ago, we stumbled upon two elderly Chinese women reduced to fisticuffs while fighting over a can of refuse outside 88 Orchard Street. The two bottle collectors were battling over the rights to the cash-refundable contents within the trash. After the scuffle was broken up, both left the scene as if nothing happened. From that […]

boss-tweeds
The ‘Grilled Cheese Incident’ Debuts Inside Boss Tweed’s on Essex Street

Boss Tweed’s on Essex Street is diversifying. Changing it up to stay relevant, perhaps. Another grilled cheese-specific operation is now underway here at 115 Essex. It’s called the Grilled Cheese Incident, a pop-up that banks heavily on the storied lore of Depression-era gangsters. The Grilled Cheese Incident was founded by fifth-generation NYC native Marc Lande as […]

beckenstein-ghost-signage
Tracing the Lower East Side Roots of Beckenstein’s [HISTORY]

Manhattan’s Lower East Side has been called many things, but never a fashion center. Yet it is fashion in the form of inexpensive fabrics that lures shoppers to this neighborhood better known for blintzes than ball gowns. -New York Times; June 5, 1961. Between the ghost advertising and left-for-dead store signage, its remnants continue to […]

  • RJJNY

    Feel bad for all those people (and their pets) every time I walk past 91 Eldirdge/289 Grand and see it still boarded up. Am increasingly paranoid about fires in our tenement on Eldridge these days, have had boiler smoke situations and one close call when a restaurant on the ground floor left something on a switched-on hotplate overnight, necessitating a Fire Dept visit at 3am and some tenant bonding outside in the snow. 

    Does anyone know what the structures on the roof of 283 Grand Street were? Have a pic here from before the fire: http://oi44.tinypic.com/4rb3u8.jpg you can see there were several rows of some weird raised slats facing south. 

    • http://nychinatown.org/ Lucky_dog89

      those structures–pointing south, and tilted upwards toward the sky–were solar panels.  

      here 
      http://gis.nyc.gov/doitt/nycitymap/ 
      you can see the structures from above, click on years 2006, and 1996 when aerial maps were available.