Demolition Drama at 143 Ludlow Street

Posted on: August 10th, 2012 at 6:09 am by and

Imagine that every night before going to bed, your apartment was sealed from the outside with plastic nailed to the door? While it sounds like a scene straight out of ET, this is routine for residents of 143 Ludlow Street.


143 Ludlow Street was recently purchased by Samy Mahfar’s SMA Equities. Mahfar also recently acquired four vacant Lower East Side parcels on East Houston near Attorney Street. Documents filed with the city reveal that a special LLC was set up (143 Ludlow SM LLC) for the $5.2 million transaction. That sale officially hit the books just a couple weeks ago. The more controversial part of the news, however, is the action taken after closing. The new owner proceeded to, according to a neighbor,  aggressively demolish five apartments inside the mid-block tenement, and residents are alleging the illegalities of this work.

Apt #18


From the moment gutting began at 143 Ludlow Street, “Priority A” emergency complaints appeared in the DOB database. The combination of dangerous living conditions and stability of the apartments have left the handful of remaining tenants inside the building rather worried. The situation escalated last week when firefighters were called to the scene after a gas pipe was jarred loose, and the scent permeated the upper floors. We happened to be ambling past the building around that time and contractors were still busy unloading bales of debris into a specialty garbage truck.

Meanwhile, for almost a week, holes in the stairway walls were exposed, leaving voids that easily cleared six stories. The issue wasn’t remedied immediately, but was eventually patched. In addition, apartment #18 lost a load-bearing wall which hasn’t been replaced, and #17 was boarded up and declared structurally unsound after a 2005 fire. The fire wall between the units was breached, and the scorched scars are still visible seven years later.

Apt. #17, fire-damaged truss without scaffolding


Equally troubling to the living conditions is the enforcement of proper safety procedure…or seemingly lack thereof. The DOB maintains that all work is currently in compliance with approved plans and permits, however a source familiar with the situation disagrees. The source, who wishes to remain anonymous, reveals that building inspectors arrive on scene frequently, yet fail to cease demolition despite “20+ likely causes for a stop-work order.” What’s more, several of these inspectors (badges #2442, #2335, and #0338) allegedly close out caller complaints remotely and without a proper site visit. As a result, DOB is currently amidst an internal investigation. Something’s definitely fishy here.

When reached for comment, the DOB press department stressed that the building has already been inspected more than ten times, and all was found “in compliance with approved plans and permits.” With regard to remote complaint resolutions, the DOB chalks that up to the appearance of duplicate complaints in the system. While entirely plausible that multiple complaints are being made for similar issues, the fact remains that residents are living in dangerous conditions and yet the construction continues.

Is this building the next to fall victim to the age-old ploy by new owners to kick out long-time tenants for upscaling? From a distance, it seems very likely and we’ll continue to follow this story and report as new details emerge.

Recent Stories

Yep Tour, a Textbook Case of Illegal Chinatown Bus Operations

Yep Tour illegally operates a Chinatown bus route out of the Lower East Side. We’ve seen this before. As previously disclosed, the company does carry a permit with the Department of Transportation, but it was issued with the Brooklyn location in mind (6010 8th Avenue). Their egregious actions around the neighborhood are rarely in check […]

100 Gates Project Reaches 75% Completion Milestone on the Lower East Side

​The widely-lauded 100 Gates Project on the Lower East Side is nearing its namesake goal. In fact, the pace of painting is picking up. The skinny: the 100 Gates Project just crossed the 75% mark. We’re told that more than 75 roll-down gates have been sheathed in murals since the campaign began last summer. Moreover, […]

Pinche Taqueria Quits Noho Location After 3-Year Stint

​No mas. The last Pinche Taqueria – which, at its height boasted three taco stands – is through for the night. Curtains. Its final day of service at 333 Lafayette Street – the largest locale – was a couple weeks ago, thanks to a purported rent hike. Meanwhile, brokers from Winick didn’t waste any time […]

Vic’s Pizza Closing Tonight After 45 Years on Essex Street; Luxury Living Coming Soon

Vic’s Pizza follows the lead of Flowers Cafe and will serve its last slice tonight (8pm) after more four decades on the Lower East Side. That’s two mom-and-pops shoved aside yet again, all in the name of that gold rush mentality. Both closures were expected, though, with plans of demolition and replacement revealed last spring. […]

Kapowski’s by Moscow 57 Goes Dark After Only 2 Months on Delancey Street

Kapowski’s went kapow last week. 168 Delancey Street is now dormant. Owner Ellen Kaye had teamed up with Barramundi principal Tony Powe back in the summertime to reinvent the concept. They brought in chef Nikita Ponomarev to help with the “Russian and Central Asian small plate” menu. The brief reinvention owed itself to the seven […]

  • Jay

    Now they are filing and being approved for demolition permits on apartments that are currently occupied.

  • Bobby

    My girlfriend lives in the building so I spent quite a lot of time there. I’m qualified to say this article is not accurate. The landlord has fully complied with the DOB and has permits for all the work that is being done. I actually met the landlord outside the building and hes a very decent man. This article is fabricated and false.

    Jay, that is impossible. Get your facts straight. ^

    • Jay

      Yes you are full of baloney – we know everyone in the building and no one’s significant other would take the new landlord’s side on anything. They would prefer we all move out in body bags.

    • James

      Your “girlfriend” is one of the five elderly tenants left? Why would the landlord speak with anyone who is not the tenant of record. Fail on credibility “Bobby.”

  • Mitch

    So this boils down to either A)This article is trying to claim that the DOB’s integrity is compromised in this issue and that the new Landlord is bribing them in order to conduct illegal and dangerous improvements OR B) The neighborhood/tenants are not happy that their building will be updated at the cost of some LEGAL inconveniences and increased rents (which are more reflective of the market in Manhattan and will be a result of the improved property)

    • Iry

      C. The building is not being updated for current tenants. The only apartments under renovation are vacant apartments updated to achieve destabilization. Homelessness is not a legal inconvenience unless you are rich.

      • Mitch

        Homelessness is a legal inconvenience if you’re living in an area you can’t afford to live in…. You can’t fight market forces if you live in a capitalistic system. Sounds to me like you think it’s right that people live somewhere while paying 75% less than their neighbors….