Judge Rules Against Robert G. Lopez in Lower East Side Trademark Spat

Posted on: August 6th, 2012 at 11:31 am by

Best sticker ever

The judge wasn’t in his corner this time around, instead ruling in favor of the defendant.

Robert G. Lopez has been on the front lines defending his Lower East Side trademark these last few years with a fairly successful track record (Aeropostale, Urban Outfitters, J. Crew). One of the more recent cases, the one against Gap Inc. over some Old Navy tees, didn’t quite work in his favor.

U.S. District Judge Paul A. Engelmayer granted Gap’s motion for summary judgement in the case, stating that Lopez “did not prove a likelihood of confusion between the two shirts that Old Navy was selling and the Lower East Side Co. products.”

When reached for comment, Lopez intimated that he’s not going down without a fight and plans to appeal the judgement. “This will not deter my efforts of enforcing my rights in the marks,” he said. “In the event that consumers are lead to believe that my products are endorsed by any other company or vice versa, then I will do what is necessary to have my day in Court.”

Meanwhile, the lawsuit against Macy’s is still pending.

Recognize.

Recent Stories

Photo: NYC Municipal Archives
On the Ground 7 Years Before the Essex Street Market Became a Reality [PHOTOS]

In the coming years, each of the Essex Street Market buildings will fall to accommodate the new Essex Crossing mega-project. The facility was built seventy-five years ago to move the plethora of pushcarts indoors. The archival photo is dated sometime in 1933, seven years before the one-story commercial buildings were constructed by order of Mayor LaGuardia. […]

Photo: Lori Greenberg
DayLife Presents ‘Lower EAT Side’ Sunday June 14

DayLife is once again kicking off the summer season with its annual outdoor LES celebration. This year’s event, sponsored by ConEd and G-Shock, is being called “Lower EAT Side.” We see what you did there. It may be a far cry from the Orchard Street pushcarts of yesteryear, but the Lower East Side BID and its semi-regular […]

Photo: Catjia Rehkamp
This Lower East Side Photographer Spent a Year Chronicling Local Can Collectors

Roughly nine years ago, we stumbled upon two elderly Chinese women reduced to fisticuffs while fighting over a can of refuse outside 88 Orchard Street. The two bottle collectors were battling over the rights to the cash-refundable contents within the trash. After the scuffle was broken up, both left the scene as if nothing happened. From that […]

boss-tweeds
The ‘Grilled Cheese Incident’ Debuts Inside Boss Tweed’s on Essex Street

Boss Tweed’s on Essex Street is diversifying. Changing it up to stay relevant, perhaps. Another grilled cheese-specific operation is now underway here at 115 Essex. It’s called the Grilled Cheese Incident, a pop-up that banks heavily on the storied lore of Depression-era gangsters. The Grilled Cheese Incident was founded by fifth-generation NYC native Marc Lande as […]

beckenstein-ghost-signage
Tracing the Lower East Side Roots of Beckenstein’s [HISTORY]

Manhattan’s Lower East Side has been called many things, but never a fashion center. Yet it is fashion in the form of inexpensive fabrics that lures shoppers to this neighborhood better known for blintzes than ball gowns. -New York Times; June 5, 1961. Between the ghost advertising and left-for-dead store signage, its remnants continue to […]

  • Jackie Alperson

    MR. LOPEZ, YOU DO NOT OWN THE PHRASE “LOWER EAST SIDE”.
    IT IS A NEIGHBORHOOD IN NEW YORK CITY.
    YOU ARE JUST GOING TO SPEND YOUR LIFE IN COURT.

  • david

    Gap is know for ripping off other designer’s work.