Pink Pony on Ludlow Closes for Good

Posted on: February 11th, 2013 at 6:09 am by

pink-pony-closed

Just like Freddie said, “another one gone, another one gone, another one bites the dust.”

Looks like Pink Pony finally succumbed to the pressures of gentrification. The pioneering Lower East Side hang at 176 Ludlow closed a couple weeks ago under cover of darkness, seemingly not to return. Drawn security gates and the colorful mural are what remain to collectively greet those former patrons seeking casual no-frills grub. No notes, missives, or thank you letters posted anywhere. Just a quiet departure.

Sources confirm closure, while calls for comment are met without success. Yes, the Pink Pony phone number was also disconnected, with a Verizon operator instead trying to connect callers with a similar business. Apparently those establishments include Olive Garden and Red Lobster. WTF.

Sad as this news is, it’s not completely surprising. We all knew this day would eventually arrive, especially after the famed compromise of January 2011 in which a favorable rent deal was struck between the landlord and neighbor Max Fish, who subleased the adjacent restaurant space to Pink Pony. At that moment, the extension granted was only for a year so both were living on borrowed time. No word on whether owner Lucien Bahaj will relocate like he had expressed during the last scare two years ago.

Fingers of blame can be pointed in numerous directions, but the two properties immediately to the north are certainly prime offenders. 180 Ludlow and the Hotel Ludlow.

How do you feel about the loss of Pink Pony?

Recent Stories

Will the real Seth Cohen please stand up?
An Update on the ‘Seth Cohen Project’ and How You Can Help This Seth Cohen Find Them All

Since we first happened upon a flyer in the East Houston median last November, one city denizen named Seth Cohen has been catapulted to international fame. You see, this guy is on a hunt to find every possible Seth Cohen around the globe, the ambitious mission of his nascent “Seth Cohen Project.” So far, the endeavor […]

amato-1995-1
A Glimpse of the Amato Opera House on the Bowery, Circa 1995 [VIDEO]

A few days after unearthing his footage of Ludlow Street in 1995, Corey Shaff shares the following clip centered on the now-defunct Amato Opera House at 319 Bowery. Where the stage was allegedly smaller than the men’s room at the Met. It was initially produced for PBS that same year, but the public broadcasting channel decided the […]

sheldon silver
Disgraced Sheldon Silver to be Replaced as Assembly Speaker on Monday

Oh, how the mighty have fallen. Disgraced Assembly Speaker (and Grand Street stalwart) Sheldon Silver, currently facing criminal charges for accepting millions in bribes and kickbacks, is on the hot seat yet refuses to resign his political post. Nevertheless, according to the New York Times, Rochester-area assemblyman Joseph D. Morelle will take the reins as […]

clinton-subway-signage
Subway to Debut Sixth 10002 Outpost on Clinton Street Next Week

The sixth Subway franchise within the confines of 10002 (not a typo) mere days from reality. Storefront signage was installed last week at 200 Clinton Street (corner of East Broadway), and teases the promise of breakfast all day (don’t forget, plastic bread). Word on the street is that it’ll open shop sometime next week. Just in […]

essex-snowman-2015
The Essex Street Snowman Makes its First Appearance of 2015

The Essex Street Snowman made his grand return to the Lower East Side yesterday. Once again, employees of the Chinese bodega at the corner of Canal spent much of yesterday afternoon gathering and amassing the gargantuan creature (and spraying water to freeze it in place). By evening, he was ready, at an approximate height of […]

  • Marbury

    I work at Ludlow Fitness and this one of my favorite places to hang out at after training clients

  • http://twitter.com/cire_e ee. e². esquared™

    Lower East Side has become just too much like the Meat Packing District and Ludlow Street is becoming like MPD’s Washington Street. Last time I was there and at a Motor City Bar, hardly anyone was there, but at the same time Spritzer’s was buzzing and when I was outside smoking, people were asking for directions to Beauty & Essex, Schiller’s, Hotel Chantelle, etc. Good times, nonetheless.

  • http://twitter.com/agentmule trace crutchfield

    the honeymoon is over

  • http://www.facebook.com/kristin.gennerich Kristin Gennerich

    Now Motor City is also closing…fu gentrification!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1254675595 Joanne RocketJsquirrel

    Motor City announced today that they’re closing as well. This city is seriously sucking a$$.

  • stinks kc

    JEROMES IS STILL OPEN GUYS

    • Super 86

      Jerome’s is wack as shit now that they’ve changed owners just saying

  • http://twitter.com/emorwee Emily Atkin

    It was too far from my apartment, it attracted too many foreigners that didn’t know how to tip and it was run by a 20 year old. But it was unique and charming and casual and I loved working there. Viva Pink Pony

  • Party Time!

    SO GLAD!!!

    Don’t you think they could do SO MUCH MORE with that space! Like a Bed, Bath and Beyond, or a William Sonoma? Also, if we could eliminate some of the skate board-types and a few of the loud minoritie-ish types (some of my best friends are African Americans btw!) but just bring up the area a bit… Also if people could smile a bit more, and wear bright clothes? I think the Lower East Side could really be something AWESOME! ; – )