The Mystery of Arlo Guthrie’s Lower East Side ‘Hootenanny Bar Mitzvah’

Posted on: May 15th, 2014 at 10:40 am by and

alices-restaurant

“Alice’s Restaurant Massacre,” more commonly referred to as “Alice’s Restaurant,” is a classic eighteen-and-a-half minute anti-war satire from the folk music canon, written and recorded by Arlo Guthrie in 1967, and traditionally played on radio stations in the Northeast at noon on Thanksgiving Day. It’s the song that put Arlo on the map, following in the footsteps of his dad, the legendary Woody Guthrie. What probably doesn’t come to mind when you listen to the lyrics is the album’s liner notes, written by producer Harold Leventhal. Therein, Leventhal recounts Arlo’s unique coming of age:

I don’t think I’ll ever forget Arlo’s folk-style Bar Mitzvah, which was held when he was about 13 1/2 years old in a Second Avenue dance studio loft, on New York’s lower East Side. Woody was there. So was Cisco Houston, Pete Seeger, The Weavers, and many others. Arlo was ushered into manhood with songs, finger pickin’, square dancing, harmonica playing, and ritual blessings in what was the first (and probably the only) Hootenanny Bar Mitzvah in history.

Capture

A seemingly innocent, albeit interesting, passage, but one that sparked enough curiosity from Boogie’s folk fan and history buff to keep on digging. Where on the Lower East Side, specifically, was Guthrie’s bar mitzvah held? Was it even a legit bar mitzvah, or was Leventhal’s declaration tongue-in-cheek? Was Arlo, in fact, a practicing member of the faith?

What we found involved conflicting sources and more six degrees of separation than we thought possible. Check it out.

Arlo Guthrie The Warner Reprise Years By Hank Reineke

“Arlo Guthrie: The Warner Reprise Years” By Hank Reineke

The Lower East Side (including the East Village) was a hotbed of folk inspiration back in the ’60s – more or less common knowledge. Arlo was immersed in the scene early on, gaining entry into clubs (despite being underage) thanks to his well-connected parents. His mother, and Woody Guthrie’s second wife, Marjorie Mazia Guthrie, danced and taught for the famous Martha Graham; at home, she provided a Jewish upbringing for Arlo. Though not Jewish himself, Woody additionally found kinship with Marjorie’s mother, the famous Yiddish poet Aliza Greenblatt. Talk about a family stacked with creativity! It’s recently come to light that Woody crafted many unrecorded songs during his lifetime, exploring the heritage and beliefs of Judaism, because of this companionship.

The Guthries agreed that Arlo should have proper tutoring for his bar mitzvah, and hired a “sweet young rabbi,” Guthrie told The Jewish Journal. The rabbi’s name was Meir Kahane, and he went on to become the extremist founder of both the Jewish Defense League and the Kach political party. He was assassinated in a Manhattan ballroom by Al Qaeda in 1990.  “Rabbi Kahane was a really nice, patient teacher,” Guthrie recalled, “but shortly after he started giving me my lessons, he started going haywire. Maybe I was responsible.”

Bob Dylan Prophet, Mystic, Poet By Seth Rogovoy

“Bob Dylan: Prophet, Mystic, Poet” By Seth Rogovoy 

But was Arlo’s bar mitzvah the real deal? We were hard-pressed to find any official accounts of the occasion. Also, according to Arlo, it’s a bit speculative. “It was mostly a bunch of guys having fun, mostly my dad’s peers who had shown up,” Guthrie told the LA Times. “My dad was brought in from the hospital. Luckily for me the attention was on him, so I was spared.” He developed a deeper connection with Judaism during his boarding school days in Stockbridge, MA, but ultimately converted to Catholicism in 1977.

And as for the exact location of the famed “bar mitzvah hootenanny,” it unfortunately remains a mystery. There were countless loft dance studios along Second Avenue – after all, it was the 1960s in New York’s most artistic neighborhood. Nowadays, it can dampen the spirits to witness the rapid changes of these neighborhoods, but it is nevertheless heartening to walk down the streets, thinking about the hootenannies that were happening in living rooms above, and knowing that some of the world’s finest creativity has tread these very sidewalks … and will continue to do so (we hope!).

Here are some images of the young Arlo to feast your eyes on.

Recent Stories

Early ’00s LES Rock History ‘Meet Me in the Bathroom’ will be Adapted into Docu-series

You may have seen this… New York’s beloved gritty indie musc scene circa 2000s is getting a second life, through a four-hour docu-series. That’s right, the resurgence is a visual retelling based on Lizzy Goodman’s 600-page oral history called Meet Me in the Bathroom: Rebirth and Rock & Roll in NYC 2001-2011. The documentary will […]

Anti-Gun Mural Painted on Hester Street

Shots fired. Muralist Otto Schade is throwing shade at gun control with this powerful new piece on Hester Street, just east of the Bowery. It was painted last week. The liberty eagle’s wingspan runs the length of the brick wall, and is composed solely of weaponry. Machine guns and knives. And the bird is clutching […]

‘Tang’s Noodle’ Joins the Leon Hotel on Canal Street

Chinatown has another noodle shop to its name. Coming soon to the four-year-old Leon Hotel is Tang’s Noodle. If the signage is to be believed, this is the first stateside restaurant for the import. Build-out of the small ten-table establishment had been underway since summertime. And it’s not to be confused with the new hotpot […]

Construction Resumes at East Broadway Modular Development Site After Collapsed Sidewalk

The modular housing construction on East Broadway reactivated in a big way last week after its second sidelining since summertime. Pile driver and backhoe are stationed onsite. The project parcel at 201 East Broadway has been relatively silent for much of the last six months. Twice in that time, progress was stymied thanks to safety […]

City Council Passes Bill for Increased ‘Urban Renewal’ Transparency

Earlier this week, City Council unanimously voted to pass legislation that would require the City to provide public access to urban renewal plans, which have been changing the real estate landscape of New York City for decades. Intro 1533-A, sponsored by Councilwoman Margaret Chin, would require the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) to […]