Serge Hoyda Files Suit to Evict Preserve 24, Alleges ‘Per Se’ Vet Purchased the Assets

Posted on: August 25th, 2014 at 5:55 am by


When it comes to nightlife failures on the Lower East Side, Preserve 24 easily ranks as one of the most epic in recent memory. The over-the-top bar-restaurant bit off way more than it could chew, and died on the vine two months ago. It mysteriously closed at the end of June for “remodeling with new ownership on the way.” Don’t hold your breath for a reopening; there is obviously more to the story…

Landlord Serge Hoyda filed suit last week to evict Preserve 24 (aka Aegis Holding Houston LLC) from 177 East Houston Street. Hoyda was “awarded a final judgement of possession in the amount of $726,761.67 with the warrant of eviction,” according to public court documents. Also named in the filing is Anthony W. Rudolf. Yep, the former General Manager of Per Se, Thomas Keller’s acclaimed restaurant.

The suit alleges that, upon closure of the restaurant on June 27, Rudolf purchased the business assets and is now the new principal of the company. Another allegation is that new ownership is “imminently about to perform renovations to the premises.” As property owner, Hoyda takes issue with this and claims that, per its lease with Aegis, the third party is not permitted to sell and Rudolf cannot begin any work. No permissions were given.


For the moment, Hoyda successfully enjoined any auction of physical assets, including a scheduled event last Thursday.

The court issued an “order to show cause” summons which is now publicly pasted in the windows. Humiliation in no uncertain terms. According to Judge Carol Edmead, the defendant restaurant must appear in court on September 8.

As we’ve previously mentioned, Preserve 24 spent more time behind plywood than open to the public. The ambitious concept bar-restaurant at the corner of Allen and East Houston was too epic out of the gate that it was destined to fail. Too elaborate; too much square-footage; too kitschy with the fictional explorer’s club story and mission to retrieve glacial ice.

Preserve 24's ice cage

Preserve 24’s ice cage

Recent Stories

‘El Luchadore’ Opening Another Wrestling-Themed Taco Stand on Ludlow Street

Word on the street is that Hell Square will soon welcome a new Mexican snack joint to its ranks, taking the reins from a failed creperie. A year into operations down by the South Street Seaport, the popular taco stand El Luchador is reportedly opening a new location on the Lower East Side. Sources disclose that the restaurant, […]

Essex Crossing Forward Base is Established on Norfolk Street

The forward communications base for Essex Crossing is now up and running on Norfolk Street. As previously reported, the Lower East Side BID “donated” several of its parking spaces in Site 3 so that the developers could maintain offices near all the action. (This parcel is not part of Phase I development.) The new command […]

Puck Building Finally Turns on Its Illuminated Sidewalks Again

The historic Puck Building at East Houston and Lafayette Street is glowing in its new identity of luxury housing. Just look to the studded base of the building itself. Let there be light. In a surprising turn of events, that “distinctive sidewalk” (in design-speak) outside the city landmark was just illuminated for the first time in […]

Ongoing Grand Street Water Main Work Winds Down East of Allen

​The reality of Phase II has set in. Grand Street east of the Bowery is a total shitshow right now. Thanks to the ongoing work around installing a trunk water main beneath the roadway, the traffic patterns are changed, and businesses likely hurting. With the interlocking system of portable fencing and construction crew in tow, […]

No More Horses in Hell Square; Equestrian Brigade Headed Back to the Stable

No more horse shit. Seriously. If you have the displeasure of walking through Hell Square during prime party hours, seek refuge in the forthcoming change of the guard. Or, rather, removal. Almost five years trampled underfoot, and with piles of manure to boot (or step in), the 7th Precinct is finally ending the practice of late-night horse […]