Whynot Coffee on Orchard Street Loses Its Wine-Beer License in SLA Ruling

Posted on: June 4th, 2015 at 5:00 am by

whynot-orchard-open

Whynot Coffee sustained a deadly blow in early May when the State Liquor Authority officially terminated its wine and beer license at 175 Orchard Street. The board unanimously stonewalled owner Emil Stepkov and his counsel (Donald Bernstein) for duping the community over its half-baked “art” concept. And for the LES Dwellers, it’s another storied victory, the second on this battered block of Orchard in as many months (i.e. Sixth Ward).

The “art-driven” coffee shop had appeared before the legal panel as part of a disciplinary hearing on various violations. Namely, ignoring the binding stipulations and changing the method of operation. Cited infractions included live music, dancers (Whynot doesn’t possess cabaret license), and loud music pumping past agreed-upon 10pm limit. Stepkov acknowledged that the “art wasn’t selling” (only two exhibitions in a year) and that there was “no point [selling it] anymore.” Given that this was the premise on which Whynot was founded, the SLA wasn’t pleased with being kept in the dark. And they made that fact known.

In the end, the SLA called bullshit, and decided to punish the problem child by canceling the wine-beer license at 175 Orchard Street. The measure is a lesser of two evils, so to speak. Stepkov can still apply for liquor at a different establishment; if it had been revocation, there’s a 3-year penalty period. Meanwhile, the license is now listed as “inactive” in the SLA database.

whynot-license

The hot-under-the-collar Bernstein, for his part, went berserk over the judgement, calling the action excessive and outlining the reasoning. He was quickly cut off by one of the SLA lawyers who told him to fuck off in as many words – “Tell me about it in your Article 78 filing (an appeal of a state decision).”

“It was pretty clear from the beginnig what [Stepkov’s ] intentions were, LES Dwellers co-founder Diem Boyd tells us. “It was to open another late night bar with DJs and music. The disingeniuos art front was exposed, and Hell Square dodged a bullet.”

“The cancelation of Whynot’s license was the result of residents saying something and doing something. This is what we are about; empowering residents to stand up to law breaking operators and ensuring law breaking operators are held to the full extent of the law.”

The irony in all this drama is that Stepkov built a business banking on the liquor license, but created a popular coffee shop instead. Whynot just leave it at that, expand the menu and increase the daytime foot traffic that the area needs? That’s the real public benefit.

Needless to say, Whynot remains in business as its name implies. Coffee. No alcohol. And probably no transformation to that suspect Sushi Wa concept, which netted Community Board 3 approval under the same strict stipulation.

However, at this point, all credibility with Stepkov seems lost at this point.

Recent Stories

Uncapped: Beneath the Paint with the Legendary AUDIE U5

This latest installment of Uncapped is more than a year in the making, and we are stoked to have Audie U5 join us. BOWERY BOOGIE: Audie U5. Welcome to the series. Instead of the cherished and/or default “what do you write?” how about, why do you write “Audie?” Audie U5: Always Undeniably Dope In Everything!  Nah, […]

Man Jumped to His Death from Ludlow Street Rooftop

A man jumped to his death from a Lower East Side tenement rooftop Wednesday night. The unidentified man, believed to be in his twenties, took the plunge from atop 175 Ludlow Street at about 11:45pm. The suicide victim reportedly lived alone in a studio apartment there, according to a report in the Daily News. An […]

Here’s a Map Showing How the Lower East Side Voted in the City Council Election Last Week

With more than a week having elapsed since the general election, the above map plots the results of the City Council District 1 race. It was a heated campaign that saw incumbent Margaret Chin fighting for her life against the upstart Christopher Marte. Chin defeated Marte by nearly 3,000 votes to secure a third term […]

Cafe Henrie Shutters on Forsyth Street After 2 Years

Cafe Henrie, the artsy eatery founded by nightlife maven (and street artist) Andre Saraiva on Forsyth Street, closed earlier this week. Thus capping two years on the block. All elements of the establishment are gone, replaced with token brown paper in the windows. In retrospect, the writing was on the wall back in the summertime […]

What’s it Like Living or Working in Hell Square? [SURVEY]

What’s it like to live and work in Hell Square? That’s the question behind the second phase of the Hunter College graduate program study that analyzed public health and safety risk of liquor density on the Lower East Side. No, this isn’t a farce. It’s a legit effort to figure out a way to make […]