Sartiano’s ‘Broken Coconut’ Health Eatery Stakes Claim to Former Other Music Space

Posted on: July 18th, 2017 at 5:00 am by

June 2017

That a trendy health eatery would replace a music mecca is anathema. But it looks like it’s happening all the same. Word on the street is that the old Other Music is to be replaced by something called the Broken Coconut and with the uppity slogan, “Eat pretty.”

Should we be surprised?

When the brown butcher paper was first taped to the windows of East 4th Street in early June, a worker inside informed us of the new lunch spot, and that it would be called the Broken Coconut. Other than that, there is virtually no information available.

Poking through federal trademark documents for the logo, it appears that the establishment is helmed by nightlife impresario Scott Sartiano. He’s the guy who co-founded places like Butter and 1Oak.

Photo: Menta

We also found this draft menu posted to Facebook by the graphic design firm Menta. An accompanying description notes the “nostalgic pastel hues for a ’60s beach vibe.”

Meanwhile, there is a new documentary in the works, via Kickstarter campaign, chronicling the twenty-year arc of Other Music. The filmmakers began shooting just as the store announced its swan song, shooting interviews with current and past staff members and notable customers. Indeed, the project includes input from musicians and actors alike – Stephin Merritt (Magnetic Fields), Ezra Koenig (Vampire Weekend), Dave Portner (Animal Collective), Daniel Kessler of (Interpol), Jason Schwartzman, and Benicio Del Toro.

The seminal indie music shop, which survived for years against Tower Records across the street, closed in June 2016. At the time, ownership cited rising rents – more than double the $6,000 monthly dole in 1995 – and the changing face of the music industry as reasons behind the closure.

Recent Stories

‘Marm Cafe’ on Clinton Street is Kaput, Transitions to ‘Bricia’

The end of the road is here for Marm Cafe. The three-year-old corner establishment at 79 Clinton Street hasn’t been open since at least mid-August, its fate finally sealed this week with those brown paper shades. We communicated with ownership via email several weeks ago and were told that the cafe was actually on holiday. […]

Celebrity Endorsed ‘Sycamore Style’ to Open Orchard Street Footwear Boutique

The search for a new retail occupant at 145 Orchard Street just came to a close. It’s been four months since Killion departed the block, but now signage is in place for the latest entrant. Another fashion boutique. Here comes Sycamore Style, a decades-old footwear brand that hawks “custom hand-dyed shoes.” According to their website, […]

In Move from Midtown, ‘Ierimonti Gallery’ Readies 55 Delancey Showroom

After Brennan & Griffin Gallery relocated to Norfolk Street last year, its former headquarters on Delancey Street remained vacant. The only action during its year-long dormancy was when Petee’s Pie used the space for its busy Thanksgiving rush last November. But now, more of the same is on the way. An art gallery from midtown […]

Judge Grants Notorious Landlord Steve Croman Reprieve for High Holidays, Postpones Sentencing

Convicted landlord Steve Croman will spend the Jewish High Holidays in the comfort of his own home instead of prison. At his hearing yesterday, Manhattan State Supreme Court Justice Jill Konviser elected to postpone the sentencing another two weeks for the observance. Prosecutors on behalf of state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman opposed the motion, but […]

With Final Votes Counted, Margaret Chin Squeaks by Marte for Third Term

The Board of Elections yesterday completed its final tally of absentee and affidavit ballots, and the results are in. Incumbent Councilwoman Margaret Chin maintained her narrow margin over challenger Christopher Marte by just over 200 votes. So, it’ll likely be another four years of the same. The results should be certified by the city at […]