Rare 200-Year-Old LES Federal Houses Are Endangered in Face of LPC Decalendaring

Posted on: December 4th, 2017 at 5:00 am by

22 East Broadway

Local preservationists are scrambling.

Word dropped last week that the Landmarks Preservation Commission may likely decalendar a pair of rare two-hundred-year-old Federal-style row houses from its agenda by the end of the year. 206 Bowery and 22 East Broadway are back on the endangered list, despite the city’s initial position as significant structures warranting consideration.

The unfortunate turn of events is owed in large part to the passage last year of the Intro. 775 bill in City Council aimed at removing the clutter, as it were, from the calendar. In order to do so, the “anti-landmark bill” essentially establishes “do or die” deadlines for landmark designations that have been stagnating. Meaning, if the LPC doesn’t vote on proposed individual landmarks within one year (two years for districts), then the proposals are removed from the docket.

206 Bowery, for its part, is one of the last intact Federal-era row houses on the Bowery. It remarkably survives in close to original condition from the first period of development along this stretch of the Bowery. The modest 2 ½-story, three bay-wide building has one-foot thick walls of Flemish-bond brickwork, a stone foundation and a gambrel roof with paired gable dormers. It was likely erected around 1825 as part of a group that included the houses sharing party walls at 202, 204 and 208 Bowery.

Many of these Federal-era buildings erected on the Bowery housed a store or workshop on the first floor with a residence on the second floor and a usable attic lit by dormer windows in the pitched roof. Beginning in the 1870s, it is believed that 206 Bowery was solely used for commercial (non-residential) purposes. And an eclectic bunch, at that – Walter Keeler, shoestore (1826-39); James Cooper, fancy goods, hosiery, threads, and needles (1839-53); Thomas Bruns, engraver (1853-60); William Wood, umbrellas and parasols (1853-74); Henry H. Pfalzgraf, cigars (1870-91); Philip and Rosalia Berg, millinery and fancy goods (1870-78); jewelers Sidonia Kampf (c. 1896-99) and Bernhard Hebald (1904-11); Tri-City Barber School (c. 1933-46); New York China Corp. (c. 1975-88); and J&D Restaurant Equipment Corp. (c. 1993-2010).

Much like 206 Bowery, the Federal-style house at 22 East Broadway retains many of its original nearly 200-year-old detail. It was constructed in 1832 for then-district attorney James Whiting and boasts peaked roof, dormers, Flemish bond brick, as well as lintels and sills on the second and third floors.  At the turn of the last century, the building served as the Chatham Square Branch of the New York Free Circulating Library. (That library now occupies 33 East Broadway across the street.)

GVSHP and other preservation-minded groups are sounding the alarm. Head here to support the landmarking of these two historic structures by sending a form letter to LPC.

Recent Stories

Bandits Lift Piggy Bank Tip Jar from Sugar Sweet Sunshine

Bah Humbug. Two thieves stole a countertop tip jar from the beloved Sugar Sweet Sunshine Thursday night. The Rivington Street bakery announced the petty, small-time hit job on Facebook with a public shaming. The jar in question was a forty-five-year-old piggy, and staff had apparently just emptied. So there wasn’t much left for taking. “It […]

CB2 to Consider Support of 200-Year-Old Federal House on the Bowery

Preservation efforts to save 206 Bowery again kicked into high gear earlier this month. Fear is rampant among these building advocates that the Landmark Preservation Commission – charged with saving the city’s beloved architecture – will let the Federal-style row house drop from its calendar at the end of this year. Led by the Greenwich […]

Replacement ‘Gem’ Found for Vacated Cafe Henrie on Forsyth Street

Cafe Henrie failed last month after two years on Forsyth Street. It was the casual hangout founded by Le Baron principal Andre Saraiva (aka street artist Mr. A). Now a month later, a new replacement is already lined up to take over 116 Forsyth Street. The outcome of Henrie in mid-November wasn’t a complete shock, […]

When Delancey Street McDonald’s Reopens, it’ll be Supersized on 2 Floors

Three months into major gut renovations, you would have no idea that McDonald’s served here for some two decades. Gone is the red-and-yellow branding (except a few “remodeling” signs), stripped from the marquee and replaced with plywood boards. But McDonald’s will indeed return to life in the coming months. Super-sized, at that. Indeed, take a […]

Early ’00s LES Rock History ‘Meet Me in the Bathroom’ will be Adapted into Docu-series

You may have seen this… New York’s beloved gritty indie musc scene circa 2000s is getting a second life, through a four-hour docu-series. That’s right, the resurgence is a visual retelling based on Lizzy Goodman’s 600-page oral history called Meet Me in the Bathroom: Rebirth and Rock & Roll in NYC 2001-2011. The documentary will […]