MacDougal Street Synagogue Closes its 97 Allen Hostel

Posted on: May 12th, 2011 at 6:18 am by

The rather shady hostel that’s been operating at 97 Allen Street, misleadingly named MacDougal Street Synagogue, is now kaput.  A pair of notices in the doorway inform prospective travelers that the jig is up, due to a “new law that went into effect May 1.”  That legislation, of course, is the “illegal hotels” bill approved by Governor Patterson last summer which requires an occupancy period of more than thirty days for “class A multiple dwellings.”

This image has been archived or removed.

As previously reported, this particular location is actually an outpost of the organization rooted on the Upper East Side at 1370 York Avenue.  A similar clampdown occurred there as well, with the DOB issuing partial vacate orders last Thursday, claiming an “illegal transient hotel.”

This image has been archived or removed.

But the game is not over for MacDougal.  The so-called synagogue, which describes itself as “a not-for-profit religious organization…that promotes a modern take on tolerance to New York City visitors from throughout the world,” is currently evoking First Amendment protections under the Constitution.  Huffington Post has more on their case:

Last year MacDougal, along with the owner of 1370 York Avenue, fired back at the city with a motion claiming that because of the First Amendment and a quirk in city rules, it should be able to expose tourists to “the teachings of tolerance without being subject to the restrictive apartment conversion requirements set forth in the New York City Administrative Code.”

However, the New York County Supreme Court denied the motion for an injunction against the city.

[Justice Barbara] Jaffe mostly ignored the synagogue’s First Amendment claims, which hinge on the tolerance programs the organization touts. Some former visitors say those programs consisted of nothing more than posters.

Recent Stories

NYPD Shut Down Adidas 99-Cent Sneaker Stunt on the Bowery Yesterday After it Turned Violent

Police yesterday morning shut down an out-of-control Bowery pop-up selling a limited-edition sneaker collaboration between adidas and AriZona Iced Tea. The huge crowds were the collective answer to the question, what happens when you sell a rare sneaker for 99 cents? The collaboration yielded two limited-quantity styles – Yung 1 and Continental. Both were available […]

Watch this Brazen Tagger Desecrate Louis Vuitton Logo on Ludlow Street

It’s clear that the locals aren’t too thrilled with the invasive Louis Vuitton pop-up at Ludlow and Rivington Streets. And one brazen tagger proved it. Midday Wednesday, a youngster jumped onto the building’s garbage bin and quickly spray-painted over the company logo. The graffiti lasted for a couple hours before it was buffed away. As […]

Katz’s Adjacent Retail Condo Sells for Record $89M

The hot pastrami sandwich at Katz’s Deli costs $22.95; the ginormous commercial condo in Ben Shaoul’s luxury development next door costs $89 million. Developer Ben Shaoul reportedly sold the retail portion of the building to the AR Global affiliate New York City REIT. Stated sale price is $88.75 million, which makes it the most expensive […]

Man’s Throat Slashed in Barbershop Bloodbath on Stanton Street

A 27-year-old man was slashed inside a barbershop on Stanton Street yesterday morning. The unidentified victim was attacked at about 11:15am while inside First Choice Barbers at 156 Stanton Street. The attacker, 35-year-old Aldo Corniel, slashed the customer in the throat; a third man saved the day by bashing the assailant with a fire extinguisher. […]

Doyers Street ‘Asphalt Art’ Ahead of Chinatown Seasonal Streets Closure

The third annual “Chinatown Seasonal Streets” initiative is upon us. As part of the program, select streets are closed to traffic to create public pedestrian space. The temporary plazas are also decorated with so-called Asphalt Art. Doyers Street had been the pilot, but this year sees the inclusionof a 5,370 square-foot area of Mott Street […]