Hold it Now: Petition to Co-Name ‘Beastie Boys Square’ Withdrawn, Requires More Community Support

Posted on: January 15th, 2014 at 5:06 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

Radio stations, TV channels, and newspapers were all in attendance for the story, yet last night did not produce the media-friendly outcome that LeRoy McCarthy and his “Beastie Boys Square” entourage had desired. Despite the mainstream momentum from across the city communications outlets, the transportation subcommittee of Community Board 3 ultimately asked the applicant to withdraw and return with more support from the surroundings.

Street co-namings have been a contentious issue in CB3 for years, leading to the creation of general guidelines in 2006. It was hoped that this would limit the number of applicants after an overabundance of co-names were approved in the mid-aughts. This history didn’t make for an easy vote during the meeting. Tense back-and-forth discussion transpired for nearly two hours as both sides debated the Beastie Boys’ overall “contribution” to the Lower East Side.

Since the application sorta falls outside said guidelines, the sticking point was whether an exception could be made on the basis that Paul’s Boutique was an “exceptional and highly acclaimed accomplishment or involvement linked to Manhattan CB3.”

Supporters argued the significance of the band in both city culture and to hip-hop as a music genre. Three speakers divulged personal stories about their love of the band and how the “quintessential New York cheerleaders” should be honored. The argument was somewhat of a stretch, and the subcommittee mentioned as much.

Opponents claimed that the Beasties didn’t have a strong enough connection to the area.  The cover panoramic photo on Paul’s Boutique was simply that, and didn’t carry the agreed-upon fifteen years of community involvement in the area. Also, the applicant did not carry enough support from the immediate vicinity (i.e. resident signatures). McCarthy only collected 17 signatures from the block, the minimum 75% of residential units set by CB3. But it wasn’t deemed enough, especially since he didn’t go into the corner buildings. And on that front, board member Teresa Pedroza relayed her experience in conaming Delancey and Clinton for her late granddaughter (Dashane Santana) two years ago. She faced a similar situation, and had to return months later with the proper number of signatures.

This image has been archived or removed.

In so many words, the biggest advocate on the panel, Chad Marlow, created the compelling argument why this should go through. Mainly that Paul’s Boutique helped with neighborhood exposure through the decades, evidenced by the more than 2 million records sold with our neighborhood emblazoned front-and-center. He argued that the output of the band and its contributions to hip-hop needed a proper home. How the designation would be more an honor for the community itself.

Ultimately the board approved the motion to withdraw the proposal so that McCarthy could return to Ludlow and Rivington to obtain signatures from the area bounded by Orchard/Essex/Stanton/Delancey. Marlow advised the applicants not to do the bare minimum (Office Space, anyone?), but to mobilize fans and “Crush it on their [Beastie Boys] behalf,” so that there wouldn’t be any doubt for a future approval.

For the record, here are the CB3 guidelines with regard to street co-namings. How do you feel about the block being renamed “Beastie Boys Square”? Should semantics impede this from happening?

CB3 Street Co-Naming Guidelines

Recent Stories

Subway Tribute to Late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Baden Ginsburg

Less than 24 hours after Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died, the street memorials started popping up around the city. Indeed, the artist largely known for manipulating city-issued signage (e.g. Aretha Franklin) struck again Saturday afternoon with a tribute to the late justice. This time, at the 50th Street subway station on the Eighth […]

Get a Piece of Mission Chinese Food Before it Closes

Mission Chinese Food is permanently closing its flagship restaurant on the Lower East Side, as previously reported. It lasted nearly six years on East Broadway before coronavirus imposed the business, like so many others. And now Mission is selling off some of its furnishings and ephemera with a stoop sale today. Items include restaurant equipment and […]

‘Sour Mouse’ Game Hall Launches on Delancey Street Next Week

Six months delayed due to the coronavirus lockdown, a basement game hall is finally set to open on the Lower East Side. Headquartered beneath 110 Delancey Street (former home of discount retailer Rainbow), Sour Mouse relies on bar games with the hope of “revitalize community” in the neighborhood. To that end, the establishment boasts billiards, shuffleboard, […]

Celebrating Rosh Hashanah in the 1900s Lower East Side [PHOTOS]

Sundown tonight marks the beginning of the Jewish new year with the holiday of Rosh Hashanah. To celebrate, below is a small collection of photos, courtesy of the Library of Congress, illustrating how Jews of the early 1900s celebrated the holiest of days while living in the ghetto of the Lower East Side. You’ll notice […]

The New Museum Returns to the Bowery from Pandemic Sidelining

After being sidelined for six months, the New Museum is back. They reopened their doors earlier this week to the public at large. As previously noted, three new exhibits will grace the space and run through the remainder of 2020; “Peter Saul: Crime and Punishment,” “Jordan Casteel: Within Reach,” and “Daiga Grantina: What Eats Around […]

Comments are closed.