Some Thoughts on Season 3 of HBO’s ‘Girls’; Worth All the Fuss?

Posted on: January 17th, 2014 at 11:22 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

Girls is a volatile subject around town, carrying all the weight of discussing politics or religion in the workplace. Love or loathe, it’s a media force that doesn’t appear to be disappearing any time soon. Over the past year, Lena Dunham and Co. spent a great deal of time on the Lower East Side, so, with wine bottle in hand, we thought to see if a third season of self-entitled “struggling” females would be worth the fuss.

HBO stacked two episodes on top of each other, presumably because the opening episode was like going over a Communications 101 syllabus on the first day of class: a slow, but necessary evil.

This image has been archived or removed.

It starts out with all the main characters in some manner of sleep, be it on their mother’s couch, a library desk, a dorm room top bunk, or Adam. The opening sequence was set to an orchestrated rendition of what could only be The Beta Band’s “Dry The Rain,” which aligned perfectly with the song’s refrain. Right out of the gate, we learn that each of the girls is dealing with something in their lives; Charlie left Marnie without rhyme or reason, Shoshanna is juggling school and sleeping around, Jessa is being intellectually tortured at rehab, and Hannah, the one who has it the most together, is working on introducing Adam to social niceties, like not being miserable when you’re hanging out with your girlfriend’s friends.

The second episode leaves rehashing by the wayside and gets right into it. The increasingly likeable Adam rents a car for Hannah and Shosh, and the three of them road trip upstate to pick up Jessa, who, unsurprisingly in just one episode, got herself kicked out of voluntary rehab. The road trip is packed with great bits: explaining the rules and repercussions of truth or dare, car dancing to Maroon 5, and the hotly debated pronunciation of Ryan Phillippe’s surname. Also, Shoshona’s self-assured idiocy is laugh-out-loud funny.

One reason to tune in this season is because it seems as though these self-absorbed characters who everybody loves to hate, are sort of humanizing. The world is still very much about them, but there’s an air of awareness for other people and their feelings, which hasn’t been all too present in the prior two seasons.

This image has been archived or removed.

But arguably, what makes Girls successful in its first two episodes (and series as a whole) is the dialogue. It’s delivered in a perfectly imperative, intellectual New York manner. It’s full of nuances, vocal inflections and fidgety body language – all of which nail this very specific demographic at this point in time. From diagnosing complicated relationships to wrestling philosophical questions like “What is your favorite utensil?”, the delivery is spot on.

On the flip side, though, the dialogue is also most likely the culprit for the haters. The show isn’t for every New Yorker; when you get to the juice of the matter, we see and hear this shit on a daily basis, and it’s annoying. On any given night, minding your own business, you can be sitting down to eat at your favorite dumpling joint, and the table next to you (without the ability to control the volume of their voices) starts spewing this type of intellectual valley-girl verbal diarrhea all over your dinner.

Yet to be fair, Lena Dunham has turned this grating characteristic into something that ultimately comes off as pretty smart and funny. Not easily detected on the surface, but through these absurd conversations and character traits, Dunham acknowledges and makes light of this group’s self-entitled martyrdom. Polarizing, yes; but it’s hard to deny that it’s clever. We are nonetheless intrigued to see where this season takes us (spoiler alert: Orchard Street).

So, do you love to hate or hate that you love Girls?

Recent Stories

Today in News About Trying Out for the Local Quidditch Squad

Yes, you read it right. There are tryouts this weekend for the local Quidditch team. The Tri-State team and its second string squad, respectively The Warriors and Rogues, are holding a recruiting session in East River Park tomorrow morning at 10:30am. The group is part of the official US Quidditch league. For the uninitiated, the […]

Coleman Playground Gets Upgrades Ahead of East River Park Closure

Coleman Playground, in the shadow of the Manhattan Bridge, is another of the parks along the Lower East Side coastline receiving upgrades due to the city’s billion-dollar resiliency project. As a result, East River Park will close for at least 3.5 years. The displaced open area is being redistributed to these other parks, with an […]

Street Vendor on the Bowery Caught with Hands Down His Pants

Caught red-handed. A street cart vendor on the Bowery was seen this week with his hands down his pants. Al Bundy style during lunchtime. Lower East Side local Snapped this photo of the food cart parked outside the TD Bank at Bowery and Canal Street. The image has already gone viral on a local level, […]

‘Parkour Expo’ this Weekend Atop Seward Park High School

Parkour enthusiasts take note: Move NYC is headed to the Lower East Side this weekend. Nomadic outfit The Movement Creative is setting up a temporary rooftop playground, composed of of 8,000lbs of metal pipe, joints, and wooden beams atop the New Design High School (nee Seward Park High School at 350 Grand Street). Movement Creative […]

66 Clinton Street Sees New Life as 8-Story Luxury Development

Two months ago, New Life of New York City sold its flagship building at 66 Clinton Street and relocated to Alphabet City. Next up, luxury living. Just last month, the nascent landowners – Vault Development and TLM Equities – filed paperwork with Department of Buildings for the new development. Set to rise eight stories, the […]