The Lower East Side has a ‘Poor Door’ of Its Own with Extell’s 13-Story Affordable-Only Tower

Posted on: October 13th, 2014 at 9:28 am by

This image has been archived or removed.

The “affordable” Extell building at 250 South St.

Separate but equal is not equal – the rally cry voiced during the civil rights movement – is also very much applicable to what’s happening down at Extell’s 250 South Street (aka 227 Cherry) project site. As previously noted, this gargantuan beast is essentially the Lower East Side iteration of the much-maligned “poor door,” a phenomenon that first appeared on the Upper West Side in another Extell development.

There are two components to the broader Extell project – a 13-floor building for “affordable” tenants, and a separate, sun-eclipsing 68-story “Tetris tower” for market rate living. The latter real estate is luxury to the nines; elite dwelling in the 790 units will have access to amenities never before seen in the neighborhood (bowling alley, pools, Turkish baths).

This image has been archived or removed.

The residential composition of the “inferior” structure is 205 total units (50% earmarked for residents) broken down as follows: (1) 49 studios, (2) 50 1BR’s, (3) 105 2BR’s, and (4) 1 spot for the super. The buildings are otherwise not connected.

But the kicker is still the separate entrance for the kid brother.

In its defense, Extell chief Gary Barnett had explained over the summer that it simply wasn’t feasible to combine both. It would be cost prohibitive to the privately-funded project, he argued, and wouldn’t net the most profit.

Community Board 3 will discuss this issue of “income segregated living” at its Land Use subcommittee meeting tomorrow night.

Recent Stories

New 12-Story Development to Rise Across from Essex Crossing on Ludlow Street

Nevermind the pandemic at the doorstep, more development must happen on the Lower East Side. New construction permits were filed this week for a twelve-story mid-block development directly across from the International School of Photography. The property in question is 89-91 Ludlow Street, two parcels which last year changed hands for $12.3 million. The filing […]

Emergency Rehab of Burned-out 70 Mulberry Street Resumes

Chinatown, and the city at large, is increasingly becoming a ghost town, devoid of pedestrians and traffic. Yet, despite the COVID-19 shutdown, work continues at the former PS23, where a devastating five-alarm fire gutted its top floors in January. The project site is apparently considered an emergency, and granted an exception to Governor Cuomo’s executive […]

Lower East Side Gets COVID-19 Testing Center at Gouverneur on Madison Street

Good news for the Lower East Side. Starting today, locals can get tested for the novel coronavirus. According to an update yesterday from U.S. Representative Carolyn Maloney, New York City Health and Hospitals is opening a COVID-19 assessment and testing center outside Gouverneur Hospital on Madison Street. Physicians will assess patients and determine whether further […]

GrandLo Cafe at Essex Crossing Shuts Down for Good

GrandLo Cafe won’t survive Covid-19. The two-year-old operation announced it’s permanently shuttering. The Grand Street Settlement’s social enterprise program at 178 Broome might be down, but they’re not entirely out. GrandLo has committed to completing their training program remotely, to keep trainees on their career pathway. There are also plans in the works to reoccupy the […]

Seattle Radio Station KEXP Posts Virtual Shows

With the absence of live performances on the music landscape, bands are taking to the internet to help music fans fill their gig going void. That being said, Seattle radio station KEXP is compiling an ongoing events calendar of virtual performances from artists all over the globe. From the KEXP website: With music festivals being […]