The Peace Pentagon on Lafayette Street Hits the Market Again as Development Opportunity

Posted on: March 2nd, 2015 at 5:11 am by

This image has been archived or removed.

The Peace Pentagon, circa 2010

For the second time in exactly five years, the storied Peace Pentagon on Lafayette Street, the decades-long haven of progressive activism owned by the AJ Muste Memorial Institute, is again on the chopping block. Price of the pitched development site is not listed (i.e. soliciting offers), but the last ask was pegged at $5.95 million. And also repped by Massey Knakal.

This time, brokers are employing the hard sell to unload the three-story neighborhood gem. Literature is complete with a glossy 46-page brochure that sings the praises of the building’s historical significance and the attraction of being in “one of the fastest growing luxury neighborhoods in New York City.” Ironic, considering the Peace Pentagon will likely be destroyed once purchased anyway. The only saving grace is that the property resides in the NoHo Historic district which offers protections.

This image has been archived or removed.

Photo: Massey Knakal

The lucky buyer will have 21,158 buildable square-feet for a new development if there’s a community facility included. Any plans would need approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission, though.

The property, alternatively known as 51-53 Bleecker Street, offers the perfect opportunity for a developer to design their own property among some of the most architecturally distinct buildings.

The property is zoned M1-5B, allowing for a commercial or hotel development as- of-right. The recently developed 51 Astor Place and re-developed 770 Broadway, have brought a large stock of office product and high quality commercial tenants to NoHo. Tenants at those buildings include IBM Watson Group, Claren Road Asset Management, St. John’s University, AOL, and J Crew. There has also been a rush of technology and fashion firms moving to the area including YouDocs, CCP Games, and Smokestack Studios. The high demand in the area has translated to rents in excess of $100/SF.

Although located in an M1-5B district, a developer could seek a special permit for residential, as multiple nearby projects have obtained a variance, in order to construct residential condominiums at 337 Lafayette Street.

Not mentioned in any of the literature is the fact that this building has a history of distress. Indeed, as the New York Times reported back in 2007, the Peace Pentagon is sinking, with only a measly scaffolding keeping it afloat. At the time, it was estimated that repair work would cost at least $1 million.

And here is a brief synopsis of that history:

In 1969, the War Resisters League bought 339 Lafayette, a three-story loft building in downtown Manhattan. WRL needed to leave its offices in the City Hall area on Beekman Street, and 339 Lafayette was the cheapest building that could be found at around $80,000. In 1974, the A.J. Muste Institute was founded in part to buy the building and maintain it as a permanent center for social change organizing. In 1978, with a dream of establishing a permanent home in New York for the nonviolence movement, the Muste Institute purchased the building from the War Resisters League and began managing it as part of its program work.

For the past nearly-forty years, the building has served as a home base for dozens of activist groups and progressive organizations working for peace. The financial support provided by renting out the commercial space on the building’s ground floor as well as the Muste Institute’s fundraising activities have allowed these groups to secure low-rent office space in a convenient location.

Recent Stories

Game Over for ‘Water World Amusements’ Arcade on Essex Street

Much like the movie of same, Water World Amusements unceremoniously sunk. The arcade, which opened just over a year ago at 35 Essex Street, is no more. Gaming cabinets remain locked in the dark retail space, while leasing signage dominates the store marquee. That this game room failed to hit is not a shock. Water […]

‘Greens and Grains’ Shutters, While Famous Hakki Readies Essex Chicken Spot

Greens and Grains is no more after a year in business, as Hell Square eats another of its own. Instead, the so-called Pizza Champion is opening a chicken-focused eatery. Hakki Akdeniz, who owns a plethora of pizzerias around the neighborhood, is planning to open Essex Chicken at 115 Essex Street. Just a few doors down […]

La Pecora Bianca to Open Another Outpost at Former Delicatessen Space on Prince Street

Delicatessen shuttered suddenly last month after eleven years in Little Italy. However, its demise is actually months in the making, and with a big-name takeover on the way, to boot. The 2,000 square-foot corner space at 265 Lafayette (aka 54 Prince) is to become the third Manhattan outpost of La Pecora Bianca. And renovations are […]

Zara Looks to Legalize its Oversized SoHo Flagship Store

The flagship Zara store on Broadway is hoping to legalize its SoHo footprint by altering the current zoning. Zara, which purchased the commercial condo at 503 Broadway in 2015 for $284 million, occupies a much larger footprint than what is permitted under the current zoning. (Former location of Old Navy from 1998 to 2015.) Once […]

Does this East Broadway Traffic Pattern Change Alleviate Bridge Congestion?

As part of the effort to address the logjam to the Williamsburg Bridge, there was a previous update to the traffic pattern near the Lower East Side on-ramp. Motorists can no longer turn onto Clinton Street from East Broadway during nighttime hours. New signs have been in place beside the signals. But has this simple […]