Toby’s Public House Closes Shop on Kenmare; Possible Charlie Bird Takeover Underway

Posted on: May 11th, 2015 at 5:00 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

Three years after its uphill struggle to install a location at 86 Kenmare, Toby’s Public House is kaput. The upscale pizzeria shuttered within the last couple weeks and the establishment is totally empty. But there is already interest from another suitor; an upscale newcomer to the SoHo scene.

Looking at the Community Board 2 agenda for this month, one Elmer Kennedy LLC is listed as applicant for a full liquor license. The business address of this corporate entity traces back to the nearly-two-year-old Charlie Bird over at 5 King Street.

However, no word just yet on whether 86 Kenmare will be a second location for the brand. Our multiple requests for comment from both Toby’s and Charlie Bird went unanswered.

This image has been archived or removed.

Meanwhile, Elmer Kennedy might meet stiff resistance, given the recent history at this address.

When Toby’s Public House first announced its expansion plans for 86 Kenmare, locals weren’t too pleased. At the time – way back in 2011 – the argument had been an over-saturartion of liquor licenses in Little Italy and a lack of commuity outreach.

There were Umpteen appearances by Toby’s at Community Board 2 licensing meetings to obtain a full OP, resulting in harsh words, lots of backlash, and denials.

Expect fireworks tomorrow night when Kennedy appears before the advisory committee.

Recent Stories

Threatened East River Park Buildings Recognized for Architectural Distinction

The following guest post was written by Deborah Wye, a member of the Lower East Side Preservation Initiative board of directors. Two East River Park Art Deco gems were recently deemed eligible for the State and National Registers of Historic Places by the New York State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). Both the Track House near […]

Suspected LES Killer Dressed as Ninja While Dismembering Tech Entrepreneur in his Condo

The gruesome butchering of a tech entrepreneur this week is playing out like the plot of a slasher movie, and has the Lower East Side on edge. According to published reports, a killer clad in ninja outfit decapitated and dismembered Fahim Saleh in his $2 million condo on East Houston Street Tuesday afternoon. The victim’s […]

There is a Rooftop Soccer Field on this Madison Street Building

The Ground is where soccer meets tar beach. Down in Chinatown, where Madison Street meets the de-mapped Mechanics Alley, beside the Manhattan Bridge, is a one-story warehouse dedicated to soccer. The Ground, which recently relocated from Monroe Street, opens later this week at 130 Madison. And with it, an indoor soccer field and rooftop pitch. […]

Revisiting the Rise of Brooks Brothers on the Lower East Side

Last week, Brooks Brothers filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, citing the coronavirus shutdown and fashion trends toward casual. Two firms are vying to acquire the 202-year-old formal wear company and inject new capital. Ergo, the time seemed appropriate to revisit the store’s connection to the Lower East Side. Brooks Brothers was actually founded near […]

Decapitated and Dismembered Man Found Inside East Houston Condo Building

The body of a decapitated, dismembered man was found inside a luxury Lower East Side condo yesterday afternoon — purportedly stuffed in plastic bags beside a power saw. According to the New York Post, police arrived at the bloody scene shortly after 3:30pm Tuesday, responding to a welfare check placed by a friend of the […]