The ‘Poor Door’ Tower on South Street that Extell Refuses to Talk About

Posted on: December 14th, 2015 at 9:29 am by


Notice how Gary Barnett and his Extell minions rarely discuss – at least in public – the affordable housing options down at the South Street development area. What some locals have taken to calling another instance of his so-called “Poor Door” policy. Seriously, it’s all about the market-rate units, over-the-top amenities, and the foreign populace he and his billion-dollar cronies hope to score as tenants.

The only visible reminder that affordable housing is being created down on South Street (aka One Manhattan Square) is the banner of exclamation affixed to the plywood shed for the “Housing New York” initiative.

What’s usually excluded from the conversation, however, is the fact that the affordable units are segregated in a separate tower designed by Dattner Architects, with fewer amenities than its 80-story market-rate sibling. Poor door living on a grand scale. This building (aka 229 Cherry Street) will rise fourteen stories and include 205 residential units across 914,334 square-feet of space. Where are the fancy renderings for this building, and will it also get a fancy name like One Manhattan Square?

Extell's controversial 80-story waterfront tower

Extell’s controversial 80-story waterfront tower

Separate but equal is never equal.

Housing New York is Mayor de Blasio’s baby, a “five borough, ten year plan” to create 200K units of affordable housing in the next decade. You can peruse the full 117-page proposal below.

In the meantime, Extell is holding another meeting to update the community tomorrow night (6:30pm at the Manny Cantor Center on East Broadway). Expects tempers and dirty laundry aired.

Mayor de Blasio's Housing Plan

Recent Stories

How to Snitch on Building Owners for Not Shoveling the Snow

After snowstorms, many building owners are guilty of neglecting the sidewalk cleanup. Some are late to it, and others just ignore altogether. Some are even chronic offenders; you know who they are if you’ve walked the Lower East Side streets enough. Here are the rules for snow or ice cleanup. Landlords basically have a four-hour […]

Vacate Order Partially Lifted After 85 Bowery Staircase Replaced

Rehabilitation of 85 Bowery hit a snag this week after workers discovered asbestos while replacing the unstable staircase. Presence of the carcinogen on the third and fourth floors means that the timetable to completion is now delayed. But the staircase is now complete, and the Department of Buildings acted in kind. The full vacate order […]

Gino Sorbillo Ditches Mulberry Street After One Year in Little Italy

Gino Sorbillo’s flagship pizzeria on the Bowery basks in the glow of the limelight – Mayor de Blasio was there for the opening – but it was actually predated several months by his Zia Esterina concept in Little Italy. Named for Sorbillo’s aunt, this location featured pizza fritta and fried calzone, and seemed like a […]

Breaking: Person Struck by Subway at East Broadway [Updated]

Shortly after 12pm, a man walking through the tunnel at the East Broadway station was struck by a northbound train. Emergency personnel responded, and quickly shut off electricity to the station to extricate the 31-year-old victim from the tracks. The man was carted away on a stretcher and taken to Bellevue Hospital with a deep cut […]

Clayton’s Corner: Of Generations and Gentrification [PHOTOS]

As the unrelenting winds of the international corporate gentrification keeps eroding away the deep, rich, soil of our culture, it also disposes of “neighborhood” and “community.” It affects both collective memory and history. For example: changing the name of PS 122 into Performance Space New York obliterates the connection to the previous 30-year history. Another […]