Comptroller Stringer Scrutinizes $116M Sale of ‘Rivington House’ for Condo Conversion

Posted on: March 24th, 2016 at 5:19 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

​You may have seen this…

City Comptroller Scott Stringer is crying foul on the $116 million sale of the former Rivington House nursing home at 45 Rivington Street earlier this year, according to a report in the Wall Street Journal this week. The buyer, Chinese-based China Vanke Co., is hoping to convert the building to luxury residential.

Quick recap: VillageCare had previously owned the 150,000 square-foot facility, but ceased operations as nursing home for AIDS patients in 2014. Allure Group, a for-profit nursing-care provider, purchased the property last November for $28 million, plus an additional $16.15 million to nullify the 1992 requirement that the property operate as a non-profit health care facility.

Stringer reportedly questioned the Department of Citywide Administration Services in a letter dated March 7, “asking the city agency for details on its decision last year to remove restrictions” that ultimately led to its purchase for $116 million. He also questioned whether the deal “shortchanged taxpayers” and was concerned about the lack of “public discussion” regarding the lifting of said restrictions.

This image has been archived or removed.

Photo: WSJ

Per the Wall Street Journal:

In early 2015, the Allure Group, a for-profit nursing care provider, purchased the building for $28 million, and months later paid the city $16.15 million to remove the restrictions that limited the building’s use, records show.

About three months after the city lifted the restrictions, Allure sold the building for $116 million to a residential developer that plans to convert it into luxury condominiums, over the objections of some community leaders.

Of­fi­cials in the may­or’s of­fice and at the De­part­ment of City­wide Ad­min­is­tra­tive Ser­vices, the agency that lifted the deed re­stric­tion, had un­der­stood at the time that the prop­erty would be turned into a for-profit nurs­ing home, Austin Fi­nan, a spokesman for Mr. de Bla­sio, said Tues­day.

Mr. Stringer, a Democrat who serves as the city’s chief financial officer, said in a statement he wanted the city to disclose the details behind the deal to ensure it was in the public’s best interest.

“It is incomprehensible that this property, which provided long-term care for patients with HIV/AIDS for more than two decades, would reportedly be converted into market-rate luxury housing without robust discussion, transparency and input from the community it serves,” Mr. Stringer said.

Asked about concerns that the $16.15 million payment shortchanged the taxpayers, Mr. Finan said the “processes by which deed restrictions are valued, and restriction removals are authorized” are under review and “subject to overhaul.”

City lobbying records show VillageCare spent $44,000 and $40,000 in 2013 and 2014, respectively, on the services of James F. Capalino & Associates, a city lobbying firm. The lobbying was focused on DCAS and the “deed restriction,” records show.

Councilwoman Margaret Chin acted as surprised as anyone else. “We thought everything was going to be fine,” she told the paper. “Now we might get stuck with a luxury condo building. This is not what the community fought for.”

Naivety runs high in city politics, apparently.

Recent Stories

PS 110 Hosting ‘Lower Eats Side’ International Food Festival Tomorrow

This weekend you can eat your way around the globe at Public School 110 (aka the Florence Nightingale School). The PTA at Public School 110 on Delancey Street is throwing a “Lower Eats Side” international food and music festival. First held in 2015 on the 110th anniversary of PS 110, this year’s food spread will […]

‘The Deuce’ Films Season 2 on the Lower East Side Today

Looks like production just resumed on the second season of HBO’s Times Square porn drama, The Deuce. The standard fluorescent “no parking” signs now dot the area north of Delancey and east of the Bowery. The above was spotted on Forsyth Street by Sara D. Roosevelt Park. While not immediately evident, “Penny Lane Productions” is […]

Why CitizenM is the Worst Neighbor on the Bowery [OP-ED]

The following editorial was written by longtime reader, and frequent commenter, Big Tim Sullivan. After a seemingly never-ending construction period, CitizenM has been “reaching out” to neighbors to enlist their help and garner support for approval of the hotel’s much-needed liquor license. (For CanteenM on the ground level and CloudM on the rooftop.) They need […]

Seward Park Co-op Votes to Deny Air Rights Deal to Developer

Big news out of Seward Park Co-op this afternoon. The votes are counted; the housing complex on Tuesday voted to deny the $54 million sale of air rights to developer Ascend Group. According to management – Charles H. Greenthal and Co. – the referendum did not yield the required two-thirds majority to pass. (Results: 690 Yes, […]

Leaderless LPC Doesn’t Bode Well for Lower East Side Historic District?

With the resignation of chair Meenakshi Srinivasan, the Landmarks Preservation Commission is now leaderless. This absence at the top currently has preservation groups around the city scrambling for a more preservation-minded replacement. Ironic, given the mission of this office. For the Lower East Side Preservation Initiative and Friends of the Lower East Side, the three-year struggle […]