That Time a Sniper Murdered a Shopkeeper on Orchard Street [HISTORY]

Posted on: March 31st, 2016 at 5:13 am by

This image has been archived or removed.

Photo: Brooklyn Daily Eagle

As controversial owner-developer Ben Shaoul constructs his ten-story condo-plex at 196 Orchard Street, we thought it fitting to exhume some of the criminal history behind this high-profile Lower East Side corner.

It was April 1934, and Mrs. Yetta Einhorn, 40, was standing in the doorway of her husband’s “cut-rate” bread shop at 198 Orchard Street. She had finished a sale and waked the customer out, according to a New York Times dispatch. That’s when a bullet struck and killed her. Einhorn’s last words were, “somebody shot me.”

Corroborated by the above photo, a crowd of gawkers from the “thickly populated” block between Houston and Stanton gathered at the scene to assess the situation.

This image has been archived or removed.

Detectives first thought the casualty was part of a “rate war” with her husband’s baker competition. But they later determined the culprit as a “sniper” who had fired off additional rounds nearby the night prior. The .22-caliber rifle bullet “passed through the left shoulder blade from the rear and ranged downward, touching the heart.”

This passage from the article still rings true, as sensitized denizens of a bustling city – “the neighborhood was not excited by the previous shots, witnesses declared, because most of the persons who had heard them dismissed them as automobile backfires.”

The same block today…

This image has been archived or removed.

Recent Stories

Sauce on the Sidelines for Another Month (at Least)

Still on the sidelines, Sauce might soon return. Workers busy with renovations inside the Rivington Street restaurant said to expect a reopening sometime “next month.” Given the apparent state of the interior, though, that seems ambitious. You’ll recall that a kitchen fire at the end of December knocked out the locals favorite (Monday nights half […]

‘Spreadhouse Cafe’ Closes After 5 Years on Suffolk Street

Spreadhouse Cafe is no more. The establishment closed down last week after spending five years at 116 Suffolk Street. A two-by-three grid of graphic printouts – featuring an image of Bartman in pose – announces the closure (“for now”) and to “stay tuned” for whatever might be next. So far, there are no updates on […]

With Kushner Likely Out, Hotel on Rivington Listed for $70M

It would appear that Kushner Companies is no longer under contract to purchase the Hotel on Rivington. The firm had entered into an agreement to acquire the twenty-story glass eyesore last November for $65 million. Six months later, the real estate firm filed a complaint in New York Supreme Court demanding that hotel ownership (Paul […]

Art Pigeon of Elizabeth Street Garden Stars in Next Season of HBO’s The Deuce

When both sides of the street are lined with 1970s gas-guzzlers, it could only mean one thing. HBO’s The Deuce is filming in the ‘hood. Viewers flocked to the first and second season of the Time Square series for a look at the seedier side of the city. Now that the show is transitioning into […]

Landlord Raphael Toledano Settles Harassment Lawsuit for $3M and Other Penalties

Controversial landlord Raphael Toledano, long a perpetrator of harassment in his residential properties, must now pay the piper. Attorney General Letitia James yesterday announced a settlement with Toledano for $3 million in damages and penalties. An independent monitor will also oversee his real estate holdings to ensure fraud and harassment has ceased. Nor is he […]