CB3 Rubs out Happy Ending with Denial of Liquor License Renewal

Posted on: June 21st, 2016 at 5:00 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

Happy Ending is still the scourge of the block, despite its lengthy tenure and subsequent change in ownership. That was the main takeaway from last night’s cumbersome SLA subcommittee meeting for Community Board 3.

Happy Ending is an art bar, remember? That was the concept pitched by co-owner, Oliver Stumm, a couple years ago. In the time since, it’s been more of the same, and battle-hardened neighbors remain stuck in the middle. The applicant decided not to show up at the last minute for its renewal hearing last night (license is up in September). But plenty of neighbors spoke against it, and the panel voted on the issue all the same.

Impassioned opponents mentioned ownership’s non-caring attitude, the alleged bathroom rapes, the encroachment of noisy patrons, velvet ropes, ubiquitous cigarette butts littering the sidewalk, and overall non-compliance with their stated method of operation. It was also revealed that Happy Ending is the number one offender in the 5th Precinct when it comes to resident complaints (roughly 135 calls to 311 in the year ending June 20, 2016). And perhaps most damning, allegations that the food is actually cooked in an apartment upstairs.

In the end, the panel decided to deny the renewal application, yet with the caveat that the State Liquor Authority consider reduce Happy Ending’s hours to conform with its stipulated method of operation (i.e. restaurant/art bar).


This image has been archived or removed.

Other nibbles…

  • That LES Junction concept that was looking to take over Paul Seres’ version of St. Jerome’s probably won’t be happening. The deal, according to Susan Stetzer, may have actually fallen apart, which explains the withdrawal three hours before the meeting. The board voted to deny the application anyway.
  • Joe Donagher and Eamon Donnelly, who together opened Barleycorn in Tribeca two years ago, are trying to open a rooftop hang for next summer. It would include 32 tables, 100 seats, an L-shaped bar beneath a retractable canvas covering, and stay open until 4am all nights according to submitted paperwork. Turns out, though, that the principals are not looking to alter the license, rather to apply for a new one altogether. More than a dozen Suffolk Street neighbors were in attendance to oppose the activation of this rooftop, plus another fifteen letters to the CB3 office. The board ultimately forced a withdrawal to submit the proper paperwork for a future agenda.
  • Gelso & Grand’s Nima Garos returned last night to present the proposal for alterations to Gracias Mama for 162 East Broadway. CB3 approved the full OP last month, but deferred to the SLA on measuring the distance to the Church of St. Teresa at 12 Rutgers Street. This revision includes removal of the take-out window, reducing the bar footprint, and relocating the front door (next to the subway entrance) in an attempt to skirt the state’s 200-foot law in order to obtain the liquor license. The panel approved the measure, but is again deferring to the city to determine whether the new entry is legal with DOB and MTA.

Recent Stories

The City is Demolishing 70 Mulberry Street without Chinatown Input

Four months after a devastating five-alarm fire, it seems the city is content to let 70 Mulberry Street meet the wrecking ball. The Department of Buikdings and Department of Citywide Administrative Services together Plan full demolition, without community input. Roughly a dozen concerned Chinatown residents “attended” the Community Board 3 Land Use committee meeting last […]

Thieves Continue to Target ‘Ginger & Lemongrass’ on Rivington Street

With coronavirus lockdown the new normal, crime is seemingly on the rise around the Lower East Side. And Ginger & Lemongrass, the two-year-old Vietnamese restaurant at 153 Rivington Street, is apparently a ripe target. The business last week fell victim to theft for the second time in as many months. “The Lower East Side is […]

There is Now a Wall of Face Mask Vending Machines on Delancey Street

On Delancey Street, face mask vending machines are multiplying like mogwai in a bathtub. Where there was one, there are now three servicing the neighborhood. As first reported on Bowery Boogie, entrepreneur David Edelman of RapidMask2Go placed a single vending machine outside 156 Delancey in late-April. Its placement went viral, and the story hit the […]

Lower East Side Ferry Route Permanently Reconfigured Due to Poor Ridership

Spring and summer usually see peak ridership for the city’s nascent ferry system. However, as with everything else these days, the novel coronavirus got in the way. In response to the ongoing crisis, the NYC Ferry program is reducing service by an additional 20-percent. Three routes are permanently reconfigured, including the Corlears Hook line, which […]

Scarr’s Pizza Reopens Today for Pickup and Delivery

On the sidelines for two months, Scarr’s Pizza reopens on the Lower East Side today. The popular Orchard Street pizzeria had shuttered in mid-March, just as the COVID-19 pandemic seized control of the city. Customers can order only for pickup or delivery (via Caviar); no slices. Still no word on how this extended closure ultimately […]