Looks Like ‘Black Tap’ and its Milkshakes will Try Where Quality Eats Failed on Ludlow Street

Posted on: July 27th, 2016 at 5:00 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

One year into its reign, SoHo-based burger joint, Black Tap, is angling to open a new location on the Lower East Side. Its address of choice for the third outpost has been hotly contested lately – 177 Ludlow Street. Yep, owner Samy Mahfar is again reaching for the realm of foodie chains for his Hell Square property.

The liquor license notices are currently pasted to the facade, alerting neighbors that Black Tap is on next month’s Community Board 3 docket. They’ll be seeking a beer-wine license for the venture. And barring any major catastrophes, it’ll probably happen. Which means long lines for their popular “garnished milkshakes” priced at $7 and $15.

You’ll recall, however, that 177 Ludlow Street was last on the radar of Stillmans’ Quality Eats, whose bid for the space was torpedoed three months ago by CB3. It was a unique twist in which the LES Dwellers Block Association backed the application – based on the track record of operational experience – despite its location within Hell Square; and given the fact that the landlord is one often considered one of the worst on the Lower East Side. The board failed to see a “public benefit” for an OP license here, and didn’t see fit to reward the “bad actor” in Samy Mahfar. Especially since it’s a new license in a saturated area.

This image has been archived or removed.

(Enrique Cruz noted that “Samy Mahfar shouldn’t be rewarded yet again” for causing the jettison of EarthMatters and setting up the space for nightlife.)

However, since full liquor is not sought, Black Tap will not need to prove “public benefit” to open here.

Joe Isidori co-founded Black Tap at Broome Street in SoHo last March. It’s named after the fact that most beer taps have a little black handle, and, according to Biz Journals, he wanted to open “a burger and beer joint, and that name suggested a well-crafted beer.” A flood of humanity followed thanks to the success of its milkshakes. So, yeah, more congestion for Hell Square…

This image has been archived or removed.

When Earth Matters closed, September 2012

Recent Stories

CB3 Returns to In-Person Meetings in July

Couch surfing while attending Community Board meetings is officially a fad of the past. Community Board 3 yesterday announced that remote meetings are discontinued effective today. “The Executive Order allowing remote meetings has expired and the Governor is not renewing the order,” CB3 stated in an email letter. “The state Open Government law does not […]

‘Library’ Condos Begin Selling on Rivington Street

A former branch of the New York Public Library is born again rich. The Horizon Group, which acquired the historic Beaux Arts library building at 61 Rivington Street in May 2018 for $8.4 million, is in the final stages of condo conversion. Sales launched yesterday at the new development, known officially as the Library. At […]

Pandemic Shift: The Lost Bleecker Bar

On March 16, 2020, New York City bars were ordered shut by the governor. While some waited for reopening, many wondered if that would happen. In “Pandemic Shift,” co-creators Andrew Hunter and Aaron Fischer captured the moments and moods of service workers in front of their closed establishments. Rhea, bartender of the dearly departed Bleecker […]

Owners Struggle to Keep Blue Moon Hotel Alive on Orchard Street

The Blue Moon Hotel is trying desperately at a revival after a challenging few years topped by the pandemic freefall. Most recently, historic 100 Orchard Street had been in the news for its potential conversion to a homeless shelter. The stream of negative headlines and pressure from the community forced the hotel to cave, and […]

City Embarks on $3.69M Rehab of Hamilton Fish Park

The city will soon embark on a new project to renovate the Hamilton Fish Park Playground on Pitt Street. Funded with a cash injection of $3.69 million by City Council Speaker Corey Johnson, the effort will enhance the playground with new features, improved safety surfacing, and more. But appears to stop short of the pool. […]