CB3 Condemns Yep Tour, Calls on City to Reverse Pike Street Bus Permit

Posted on: April 7th, 2017 at 5:00 am by

yep-tour-pike_wm

Spare the rod, spoil Yep Tour.

That seems to be what’s happening. Yep Tour, one of the worst bus operators in Chinatown, was awarded a six-month bus stop on Pike Street last month. The community, for its part, feels betrayed by the city’s decision to exercise this “nuclear option,” and this week’s Transportation subcommittee meeting of Community Board 3 had the feeling of an all-hands-on-deck strategy session for next steps.

It had been a watershed moment, and one of disbelief. Upon seeing a Yep Tour bus seized by the Sheriff, fed-up residents thought the tide finally turned against the vigilante Chinatown bus operator. Especially after a slew of additional bus confiscations and accumulation of fines toward its outstanding sum of $300K-plus in unpaid summonses. District Manager Susan Stetzer even noted the apparent momentum ever since the town hall in 2015. Local enforcement, Department of Transportation, and elected officials all seemed to be on the same page.

But the proverbial winds powering those sails quickly deflated when Yep Tour filed a federal lawsuit against the city (DOT, Sheriff, Department of Finance) in mid-February, a legal response spurred by the auctioning of its buses.

In the complaint, Yep alleges that it “applied numerous times for numerous bus stop” permits but was “denied each time with nothing more than an arbitrary reason of inconvenience,” when fact is that CB3 twice denied Yep a permit to operate on Pike Street due to its wanton disregard for the community and the law; that the “NYCDOT issued more than forty bus stop permits to the ‘Hampton Jitney’ and ten bus stop permits to ‘7 Bus’, both bus companies only transport passengers to-and-from New York City to the Hamptons” to support its baseless allegation that New York City has “been unfairly selective as to which companies are receiving bus stop permits”; that the way in which designated bus stop permits are issued is “arbitrary” and constitutes “protectionist measures intended to benefit New York based transportation companies at the expense of” non-New York transportation companies, despite CB3’s aforementioned deinals (and later by DOT); and worst of all, the accusation that the City of New York was racist for “arbitrarily and purposely [denying] plaintiff a bus stop on the basis that plaintiff operates from a minority neighborhood and more than 80% of plaintiff’s clientele are minorities,” when several other bus stop permits were issued to other operators in the area.

yep-tour-double-park_wm

The judge apparently decided against an injunction, and instructed the parties to reach settlement. Hence, the permit to operate on Pike Street. What’s curious is that the city was so quick to award a bus stop, even if only temporary. As Chair Chad Marlow noted, there were a host of other potential measures to negotiate this settlement, including a return of buses. Instead, this “nuclear option” was exercised.

The board spent hours crafting a resolution that effectively conveyed the collective frustration, disappointment, and outrage from both the community and elected officials.

“The granting of the designated bus stop permit to Yep Tour, Inc. severely undermines the work of every governmental, community, and law enforcement collaborator on the intercity bus issue in our district,” the strongly worded resolution states. It further concludes that “CB3 rejects and condemns any allegations by Yep Tour, Inc., in its lawsuit against the City of New York, that assert the decision to deny Yep Tours, Inc. a designated bus stop permit was based upon racial bias [or] a bias against bus companies that operate outside the State of New York.”

Long lines for Yep buses on Pike St.

Long lines for Yep buses on Pike St.

Below is the entire draft resolution from committee, which, if ratified by the full board, will be sent to the city’s Law Department and the Department of Transportation.

CB3 Resolution on Yep Tour by BoweryBoogie on Scribd

Recent Stories

Gigs to See on the Downtown Music Circuit the Month of August

The downtown music scene is approaching pre-pandemic levels, thanks in large part to increased bookings at many bars, restaurants and nightclubs. August looks more promising than any schedule in the past 16 months. Here are some highlights of upcoming shows this month, along with photographs from a few of the more active venues in July. […]

The Double-Decker Dining Shed on East 4th Street that Almost Happened

The dining shed as we know it is moving on up. Literally. Outside the Izakaya NYC on East 4th Street, workers were spotted assembling a double-decker dining shed on Friday morning. Complete with stairs, second floor, and astroturf. With the mezzanine at eye level with the first-floor apartments. By the evening, word was out and […]

Nolita Sommelier Charged with Setting Fire to Downtown Dining Structures

Photo: Forsythia Fire Department brass last week announced charges against a celebrated sommelier for setting fire to downtown dining structures. Caleb Ganzer, sommelier and partner at wine bar La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels on Centre Street, was arrested and charged with two counts of felony for three instances of arson, including two at outdoor dining […]

Exit through the Ludlow Street Food Court

Exit through the food court. Indeed, the vacant Ludlow Street lot made famous by Banksy over a decade ago is now a mini food court. Under the radar, too. The first day of operations at 159 Ludlow was apparently Friday, including two food trucks, produce vendors, and picnic table seating. One of the vendors is […]

Stringer Punts on East Side Coastal Resilience Contract

For advocates of East River Park, a brief reprieve. City Comptroller, and former mayoral candidate Scott Stringer did not sign the $1.2 billion construction contract with IPC Resiliency Partners that would kickstart city funding for the East Side Coastal Resilience project. It apparently boils down to missing info and the review period having elapsed. “As […]