Witnessing the Destruction of Beth Hamedrash Hagadol Synagogue [PHOTOS]

Posted on: December 11th, 2017 at 5:00 am by

Chisel and drill are fully deployed to dispense with one of the oldest synagogues in New York City. Beth Hamedrash Hagadol – constructed in 1850 and hollowed out by three-alarm fire last May – is being demolished as we speak. Literally brick by brick.

Each day, the landmarked 167-year-old house of worship (closed and vacant since 2007) is whittled down further, with the wrecking crew sky-high in a cherry picker perch. This is what’s left of the Norfolk Street synagogue as of this morning. Gone is the full north wall.

The demolition work is reportedly under careful watch of an engineer hired by the Landmarks Preservation Commission, and includes removal of the building walls until the structure is deemed at a “stable level.” Marching orders are to save as much of the historic site as possible before incorporating the remainder into the proposed development.

Said development would be an extension of the Hong Ning senior housing project next door at 40 Norfolk street. Tentative plans call for the Chinese-American Planning Council to expand the existing residence onto both the synagogue site and its parking lot, aided by the purchase of the neighboring air rights (assessed pre-fire at roughly $12 million). The new construction will likely include significant affordability, and a community center for the Jewish and Chinese communities.

It’s worth noting that this plan was allegedly topic of conversation between Rabbi Greenbaum and the Planning Council before the 14-year-old arsonist torched the building. Not really public knowledge until the Community Board 3 Landmarks subcommittee meeting last July, though.

(The latest proposal for the new development was to go before CB3 consideration this past September, but was scratched from the agenda.)

Recent Stories

10-Story ODA Condo Tops out on Chrystie Street

One of two ODA-designed condo towers along Chrystie just reached the top. The construction at 165 Chrystie Street topped out within the last couple weeks, boasting the token visuals of vertical completion. Flags. Not one, two, or three, but four national flags. A veritable United Nations forum with America, Russia, China, and Israel. Reaching this […]

Disarmed: Partner Dispute Leads to Shutter of Suffolk Arms

Suffolk Arms mysteriously shuttered during the first week of April due to “renovations” and “mechanical upgrades.” Sounds convincing … not. Apparently, the closure is related to a dispute between co-owners Giuseppe González and well-regarded bartender Ruben Rodriguez. The former allegedly sought the ouster of the latter this past winter. However, according to a report in […]

More on that Norfolk Street ‘Animal House’

Shenanigans at the so-called “Animal House” on Norfolk Street are under police scrutiny. But the landlord apparently isn’t playing ball. To recap… For the better part of the last year, rowdy residents of 180-182 Norfolk Street have reportedly been partying like crazy, without regard for the surroundings. Neighbors continue to tell us that the get-togethers […]

Commissioner Overseeing Office of Nightlife Hosts Open Discussion on LES Tomorrow Night

When Mayor de Blasio first announced the Office of Nightlife last year, battle-hardened residents around the Lower East Side weren’t particularly pleased. Was this new bureau just a boon to the industry at the expense of communities? How effective would a liaison be? The appointment of former Sutra owner Ariel Palitz to “Night Mayor” likewise […]

‘Kodawari’ Coffee Shop Starts Grinding at 100 Forsyth Street

Gentrification 101: When upscaling a building on the Lower East Side, install a trendy coffee shop on the ground floor. Maybe even add a little gallery art as flare. That seems to be the narrative at 100 Forsyth Street, too, an address plagued with retail problems in recent years, likely due to ongoing renovations. Something […]