Witnessing the Destruction of Beth Hamedrash Hagadol Synagogue [PHOTOS]

Posted on: December 11th, 2017 at 5:00 am by

Chisel and drill are fully deployed to dispense with one of the oldest synagogues in New York City. Beth Hamedrash Hagadol – constructed in 1850 and hollowed out by three-alarm fire last May – is being demolished as we speak. Literally brick by brick.

Each day, the landmarked 167-year-old house of worship (closed and vacant since 2007) is whittled down further, with the wrecking crew sky-high in a cherry picker perch. This is what’s left of the Norfolk Street synagogue as of this morning. Gone is the full north wall.

The demolition work is reportedly under careful watch of an engineer hired by the Landmarks Preservation Commission, and includes removal of the building walls until the structure is deemed at a “stable level.” Marching orders are to save as much of the historic site as possible before incorporating the remainder into the proposed development.

Said development would be an extension of the Hong Ning senior housing project next door at 40 Norfolk street. Tentative plans call for the Chinese-American Planning Council to expand the existing residence onto both the synagogue site and its parking lot, aided by the purchase of the neighboring air rights (assessed pre-fire at roughly $12 million). The new construction will likely include significant affordability, and a community center for the Jewish and Chinese communities.

It’s worth noting that this plan was allegedly topic of conversation between Rabbi Greenbaum and the Planning Council before the 14-year-old arsonist torched the building. Not really public knowledge until the Community Board 3 Landmarks subcommittee meeting last July, though.

(The latest proposal for the new development was to go before CB3 consideration this past September, but was scratched from the agenda.)

Recent Stories

‘Parkour Expo’ this Weekend Atop Seward Park High School

Parkour enthusiasts take note: Move NYC is headed to the Lower East Side this weekend. Nomadic outfit The Movement Creative is setting up a temporary rooftop playground, composed of of 8,000lbs of metal pipe, joints, and wooden beams atop the New Design High School (nee Seward Park High School at 350 Grand Street). Movement Creative […]

66 Clinton Street Sees New Life as 8-Story Luxury Development

Two months ago, New Life of New York City sold its flagship building at 66 Clinton Street and relocated to Alphabet City. Next up, luxury living. Just last month, the nascent landowners – Vault Development and TLM Equities – filed paperwork with Department of Buildings for the new development. Set to rise eight stories, the […]

Mayor de Blasio’s Flawed Jail Plan Leaves Inmates Further from Home [Op-Ed]

As summer winds down, we head ever-closer to the city-wide ULURP hearings on the proposed borough-based prison plan. All said and done, it’s been one big farce the past several months, through various public hearings in four boroughs held by city agencies (save the respective community boards). At each turn, neighborhoods rallied to oppose Mayor […]

The Ten-Story Development Now Atop the East Village’s Last Gas Station

It was the neighborhood’s last gas station to shutter. Now, it’s a ten-story luxury development. Foundation was first poured for 11 Avenue C way back in December 2016. The timeline upon its conception two years earlier was a fourteen-month construction period. As of this week, the superstructure is pretty much topped out. Rotwein + Blake […]

Eldridge Street’s Formosa Cafe Folds

Casual Taiwanese establishment, Formosa Cafe, is finished. The Eldridge Street hangout hung it up earlier this month. Token tombstone signage now hangs from the cartoony marquee. The Lower East Side location is survived by an outpost in Sunset Park, Brooklyn. Formosa debuted at 34 Eldridge back in May 2015. It was a large, accommodating space […]