Incarcerated Croman Files Suit Against Caffe Vivaldi, Owner Says

Posted on: May 29th, 2018 at 5:16 am by

With controversial landlord Steve Croman mere days from prison release (next Sunday), one of his victims is speaking out. Not a resident, but the 35-year-old Caffe Vivaldi on Jones Street in the West Village. The long-running establishment has been threatened ever since Croman took over back in 2011.

Below is an update to customers from embattled owner Ishrat Ansari, who recently suffered a stress-induced stroke. “I want to let you all know that Mr. Croman, a convicted felon, is taking us to court again, and we might be forced to close our doors,” he says.

Dear Friends of Caffe Vivaldi,

It’s been almost two years since my last update to all of you. Most of you do not know that for the last 20 months, I have been undergoing slow recovery from a stroke resulting after a long period of extreme and constant stress. My untimely stroke occurred two weeks before a crucial court hearing about the Caffe’s future—that has continued to drag on to the present.

In 2011, my tormentor, Steven Croman, became the new owner of the building where Caffe Vivaldi resides. From the beginning, his conduct has been belligerent and illegal, unilaterally breaking the renewed lease, which commenced on January 1, 2012, that I signed with him for the Caffe Vivaldi space, and treating me with dismissive contempt.

My emotional distress reached its most damaging state as Mr. Croman’s conduct towards me rose further and further above the law. The menace that Mr. Croman continues to pose threatens to destroy 35 years of history nurtured by Caffe Vivaldi in the West Village.

I am still not even close to full recovery, with many challenges ahead. My cognitive deficits especially have forced me to take a backseat in making decisions for the Caffe, and have prevented me from continuing to take full and strategic action against Mr. Croman.

I want to let you all know that Mr. Croman, a convicted felon, is taking us to court again, and we might be forced to close our doors.

As you might know, on February 27, 2013, New York State Civil Court Judge Lynn R. Kotler, declared Caffe Vivaldi to be a “cultural institution,” and dismissed Mr. Croman’s case against us, noting that in essence, Caffe Vivaldi had been partially evicted by the landlord from the space allowed in the lease. This ruling in essence helped us keep the vision and history of Caffe Vivaldi alive.

You have stood beside us on many occasions since Mr. Croman took over as landlord at 32 Jones Street. Over 5,000 of you have signed on to a petition to help us avoid an outrageous rent increase of almost 400%; you’ve supported us to soundproof the Caffe when we revamped our business strategy due to Croman’s interference; and another 1,561 of you have rallied to our side during our ongoing civil lawsuits with Mr. Croman.

I and the Caffe Vivaldi family wish to thank you for your ongoing generous goodwill and support throughout the years.  Over the next few weeks, we will keep you informed as things develop.

Thank you for keeping Caffe Vivaldi alive.

With love and gratitude,


Recent Stories

‘Open Streets’ Create Open Trash Mess on Lower East Side

The intersection of Orchard and Broome Streets has become a dumping grounds on weekends, according to several neighbors. Comparisons abound to Hell Square immediately north of Delancey Street. This block, like many others, takes advantage of the city’s “Open Streets” plan that allows restaurants to push onto the streets and sidewalks to serve customers. A […]

Getting by: Hugging Trees with Vicki Rovere on Ludlow Street

In our ongoing series “Getting By,” Lower East Side residents and business owners share, in their own words, how they’re navigating the new normal of pandemic times. In this installment, operator of the longtime Ludlow Street Free Store, Vicki Rovere, penned her thoughts. I live alone, and after a while in lockdown, I really hankered […]

Sam Chang Plans 13-Story Hotel to Replace Chinatown Garage

Another downtown parking garage is doomed for replacement, with a new hotel on the way. Down at 62 Mulberry Street, the five-floor car-park is ready for redevelopment. Prolific hotelier Sam Chang is gunning to construct a thirteen-story beast, with design by frequent collaborator Gene Kaufman Architect. The proposed hotel will boast 103 keys spread across […]

Nitecap Says Goodnight to Rivington Street After Six Years

Nitecap probably needs one right about now. The basement bar – founded in 2014 by David Kaplan and Alex Day of Death & Co. fame – announced its permanent closure on Instagram last night, citing challenges due to COVID-19 and debts still owed. Nitecap closed down, with the rest of the city, at the outset […]

Yeah Yeah Yeahs Celebrate 20 Years by Sharing Footage from First Show at Mercury Lounge

You’re old. But you were young then. Perhaps you caught a fringe group at Mercury Lounge that night twenty years ago. Yeah Yeah Yeahs were just another on a stacked bill September 25, 2000, alongside other relative unknowns, including Candy Darlings, Kid Congo Powers, and The White Stripes (who had released their debut record months […]