Jarmulowsky Bank Hotel License Sails through CB3, Despite Local Opposition

Posted on: October 16th, 2018 at 5:03 am by

When block associations don’t work together, the residents lose. That’s essentially the narrative behind the Jarmulowsky Bank Hotel and the approval of its liquor license last week.

Dozens of residents attended the Community Board 3 SLA subcommittee meeting last Tuesday in opposition to the hotel’s food and beverage plans at 9 Orchard Street. Namely, to operate a combination of nine public and private spaces with full liquor privileges, several of them until 4am.

Many attendees who had been informed about the project by the Orchard Street Block Association were surprised to learn that SPaCE Block Association had already cut a behind-closed-doors deal with developer DLJ Real Estate Partners. One that supports operating with 4am closure at two public bars and two private event spaces with a total capacity of more than 375 people.

During the meeting, the SLA subcommittee proposed to reduce the lobby lounge and another restaurant/bar’s opening hours. Otherwise, the panel largely followed, and approved, the SPaCE agreement, which maintains 4am closing times in the cellar cocktail bar and two private event spaces.

Orchard Street Block Association had met with DLJ several times, organized public meetings for the Jarmulowsky Bank hotel which were attended by approximately 45 local residents, and attracted at least 35 supporters of the OSBA plan at the SLA committee meeting, many of them attending for the first time. Finally, OSBA’s online petition in support of its proposal for reasonable hours currently boasts more than 200 signatures. SPaCE, on the other hand, was represented by three people, one of whom is a previous CB3 member.

We understand that OSBA had attempted to work toward an agreement with SPaCE that the community could support; however, those attempts went unrealized. In the process of exploring a joint meeting between the developers and community stakeholders, SPaCE’s leader Emma Culbert reportedly declined.

“We are frustrated that the voices of 200 people are being drowned out by 4 or 5 members of a community organization that claims to represent the neighborhood,” said OSBA’s Tamara Daley. “Residents are terrified of the impact this nightlife hotel will have on their lives and want to know why it is being granted hours that are out of line with other neighborhood businesses. SPaCE cut a deal with developers but they do not represent the community, and we call on the Community Board to recognize the overwhelming opposition to their proposal.”

More than a dozen residents and local business owners spoke last week in support of the OSBA proposal, including the owners of Little Canal and Metrograph, State Committee member Chris Marte, and OSBA’s Pamela Yeh, who spoke about the lack of outreach to the Chinese community.

OSBA also submitted a letter to the CB3 from the abbess of Cheng Chio Buddhist Temple, along with detailed maps showing its entrances within 200 feet from both the entrances to the hotel. The Committee recognized the distance to the Temple at Canal and Allen and recommended that the SLA further investigate. Said Yeh, “the SLA Committee should have recognized the temple as an integral part of the community and asked the applicant to withdraw its application, as it has with other hotel applications. Why did the Committee then agree to most of the applicant’s terms?”

The full board will vote on the matter at the end of the month.

Recent Stories

Are We Really the Fairest Big City with a Mayor for the 1%? [Op-Ed]

The following editorial was written by David Tieu on behalf of Youth Against Displacement, a group formed by youth across the City who aim to stand up against the Mayor’s pro-developer agenda and protect our communities from displacement. Last week, New Yorkers were greeted with two new proposals from the de Blasio administration: a “municipal […]

‘The Forward’ Ceases Print Publication After 121 Years

The Forward will do so without its print edition. The 121-year-old Jewish-American publication, founded as the Yiddish language Jewish Daily Forward on the Lower East Side in 1897, suspended print operations this week and will refocus efforts toward its online verticals. As a result, forty percent of the staff was reportedly laid off, including editor-in-chief […]

RIP Lower East Side Man in White, ‘Jimmy Blanco’

It’s a sad day for the Lower East Side. Jimmy Becker, known colloquially as “Jimmy Blanco” for perennially roaming the streets dressed in all white, passed away this week after a battle with Lymphoma. It’s believed he was about 69 or 70. Apparently, a neighbor in his building called EMS a couple weeks ago after […]

Tictail Brick-and-Mortar Market on Orchard Street Goes Under

Tictail officially closed down its Lower East Side market last month. The former shop at 90 Orchard Street is now a vacancy with the token farewell letter on the door. This retail surrender follows just a short while after the Swedish startup’s high-profile acquisition by Shopify. As for what’s next, expect nightlife of some sort. […]

More on ‘Gouie New York’ Sake Bar at the Market Line

The team behind Itzakaya, Davelle, and Samurice is multiplying again on the Lower East Side. More specifically, joining the ever-swelling roster of the Market Line concourse at Essex Crossing. As previously reported, the entity is to be a Japanese sake bar called Gouie New York. And now we have some additional details, including sample menu […]