LPC Approves Additional Demolition of Beth Hamedrash Hagadol

Posted on: October 3rd, 2018 at 5:08 am by

The Landmarks Preservations Commission yesterday approved additional demolition of the fire-scorched Beth Hamedrash Hagadol synagogue on Norfolk Street.

The city agency had previously okayed the prior demolition, but the development team – which includes the Chinese-American Planning Council and Dattner Architects – returned this week claiming more portions of the surviving structure were unsafe and unstable. They argued removal was necessary in order for the redevelopment of the property to progress.

According to Curbed, most of the commissioners agreed that the synagogue is destroyed beyond repair, and as such, no longer constitutes a New York City landmark. However, Commissioner Michael Devonshire asked the developers to preserve the surviving tower and the lancet window.

As previously reported in detail, the plan is to incorporate the charred synagogue remains into a larger, two-towered development. Footprint of the new project – an “intergenerational community anchored by neighborhood retail and community facility tenants” – spans the full block of Broome Street from Norfolk to Suffolk Street, and comprises both mid-rise (10 stories) and high-rise (30 stories) pieces. It’ll occupy the parking lot of the Hong Ning senior living next door (managed by CPC) and the synagogue site.

Regarding design, Dattner Architects (also involved in nearby Essex Crossing) cited potential inspirations – the James Polshek-designed entrance pavilion for the McKim, Mead, and White-designed Brooklyn Museum, as well as the Kolumba Museum in Cologne, Germany.

Similarly at Beth Hamerdash, Dattner pitched a street-facing, glass-enclosed vestibule, which will protect the synagogue remnants from the elements, create a new congregation entrance, as well as a museum display for surviving artifacts. The proposal also includes using the existing perimeter walls as garden walls for a new outdoor space for the synagogue. One of the two residential buildings would then cantilever over the remains.

Recent Stories

Claw Money Closes Delancey Street Boutique

Street artist Claw Money recently closed down her Delancey Street store. Now encased in plywood shed, the space is undergoing renovation. And joins the litter of other commercial vacancies at 101 Delancey. Indeed, the handful of divided storefronts comprising 101 Delancey went under the knife nearly a decade ago, and largely remained dormant. Except for […]

Happy Ending for the Good Luck Spa as it Reopens on Orchard Street

The good luck is back, as the Chinatown spa of same just reopened. You’ll recall that the Good Luck Spa on Orchard Street fell victim to a police sting last month, and was busted for prostitution. The proverbial happy ending treatment for customers. The business only remained closed for a minute, and was back at […]

Carbon Monoxide Leak at Broome Street Bodega Sickens 5 People

Carbon monoxide levels spiked at a Broome Street bodega early yesterday morning, sickening five people. The purported gas leak happened at the Optimum Gourmet Deli on the ground floor of 243 Broome. Firefighters rushed to the store at 7:40am. Five were sickened by the elevated gas in the air, including one who was seriously hurt. […]

Discover Opportunity with Manhattan Charter Schools [Sponsor]

We, the Manhattan Charter School for Curious Minds, are two small public elementary schools educating children in grades Kindergarten through 5th. We believe in the importance of an intimate learning environment and are committed to offering a well-rounded education designed to help students develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills. There are never more than 25 […]

Art Basel Banana Surfaces on Essex Street

Not since Velvet Underground has a banana polarized so. You may have seen the viral story about the banana fastened to a wall at Art Basel fetching $120,000 in the name of “art.” Back home on the Lower East Side, the locals have added their two cents about Maurizio Cattelan’s work (known for the golden […]