MoMA Wins Trademark Injunction Against ‘MoMaCha’ Cafe on the Bowery

Posted on: October 2nd, 2018 at 5:00 am by

That headline-grabbing art-cafe on the Bowery, MoMaCha, is in hot water and will need to change its tune.

As expected by many, the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) filed a lawsuit five months ago, and last week won a preliminary injunction in federal court against the tea room, forbidding the business from using or promoting the trademarks MOMA and MOMACHA.

Judge Louis Stanton of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District wrote, “Because the Museum has demonstrated irreparable harm, a likelihood of success on the merits, sufficiently serious questions going to the merits to make them a fair ground for litigation, and that the balance of hardships tilts in its favor, the Museum is entitled to a preliminary injunction.”

This isn’t too surprising given the nature of the cafe’s name and near-identical logo. In fact, the court also found that MoMaCha likely did not act in good faith, intentionally copying MoMA’s trademarks.

Was this all just a failed publicity stunt to drum up business at 312 Bowery?

From the media alert:

The US District Court for the Southern District of New York wrote in an opinion on Friday that MoMaCha’s use of “MOMA” and “MOMACHA” “creates a likelihood of customer confusion” with The Museum’s well-known MoMA trademark, leading customers to mistakenly believe that the art-café and MoMA are affiliated.

If MoMaCha was not ordered to stop using those two trademarks, US District Judge Louis Stanton wrote that “consumers will continue to be confused when they see MOMACHA’s advertising, press coverage, retail products, and social media accounts.” The court based its reasoning on factors including the visual similarity of parties’ marks, competitive proximity of the products, level of sophistication of the purchasers, and actual customer confusion.

Recent Stories

Bird Watching on the Lower East Side this Weekend

Binoculars at the ready! This weekend, the Urban Park Rangers from the Department of Parks and Recreation are hosting a birding session on the Lower East Side. The Rangers will guide enthusiasts of all levels to the best spots in the neighborhood, and the city at large, to catch fall migratory birds in action. Bring […]

Bank of America Plants itself Beside Destroyed Sunshine Cinema

With a commercial office building rising on the ashes of the Sunshine Cinema, it’s no wonder that a retail bank is moving in next door. Bank of America is planting itself in the long-fallow shop at the southwest corner of East Houston and Eldridge Streets. Work permits on file with the Department of Buildings give […]

Essex Market Shut Down for Private Maker’s Mark Event, Leaving Locals Confused [Updated]

The following guest post was written by Joshua Cohen, a Lower East Side resident and patron of Essex Market. I think the Essex Market, generally speaking, has been a great model for public-private partnerships. But last night, the Market hosted a private event for Maker’s Mark whiskey, where the local community’s interested were certainly not […]

T-Mobile is Closing its Delancey Street Store

Lots of retail turnover on Delancey Street this month. Earlier this week, we broke news of Rainbow’s imminent departure from the thoroughfare after more than a decade in the neighborhood. Today, it’s the loss of another corporate footprint. Though, one with arguably less utility. The eleven-year-old T-Mobile outpost, essentially an advertising expense for the wireless […]

Speed Cameras Installed on Pike Street

As part of the city’s push to capitalize on pedal-heavy motorists, new speed zones and cameras are proliferating. The latest in the neighborhood is outside Rutgers Houses on Pike Street. The camera box installation appeared within the last couple weeks, affixed to a lamppost between Cherry and Madison Streets. As with other locations, when the […]