Why Does CB3 Want to be in Bed with the BID?

Posted on: November 29th, 2018 at 5:00 am by

Lower East Side Partnership logo

It seems rather curious. Why do the top dogs of Community Board 3 want so badly to be in bed with the Lower East Side Partnership?

As previously reported, the SLA subcommittee of Community Board 3 heard a proposal by the Lower East Side Partnership earlier this month that would see the business improvement district become part of the liquor license application process. Needless to say, the appearance on the agenda has since caused confusion amongst board members and angered many residents in the neighborhood already worn down by an over-saturation of bars.

There are three parts to the BID’s proposal – help vet new licensees, assist with the application submission paperwork, and police license stipulations (even though this responsibility falls under the purview of NYPD and SLA).

Locals argue the proposed relationship will stymie democracy and proliferate nightlife even further, while proponents like District Manager Susan Stetzer (also sitting member of Nightlife Advisory Board) and Chair Alysha Coleman are the biggest cheerleaders. Arguing that this arrangement could “streamline” the process and relieve the overburdened SLA subcommittee.

Tim Laughlin of the Lower East Side Partnership

In a bid to assuage the negative sentiment, though, the CB3 Executive Committee revisited the measure last Tuesday, and invited Partnership president Tim Laughlin to return. The public meeting seemed to further galvanize the division amongst the ranks of CB3 and reveal how those at the top are really pushing for this marriage.

Indeed, roughly three hours before the meeting, Susan Stetzer allegedly informed Stuart Zamsky from the 5th Street Block Association that the planned discussion about the BID proposal was canceled. Schedules were cleared. However, the show went on, and Laughlin presented anyway. And again met resistance from within.

During the public meeting, board secretary Clint Smeltzer argued how the whole proposal was poorly prepared and requires additional scrutiny. And how the presentation at committee “was a disaster” and different from what was shown last week.

SLA subcommittee chair Alex Militano echoed that notion and mentioned that the public was left out of the process and that there should be greater transparency. She explained that the huge turnout earlier this month demonstrated that the public is indeed weary and concerned about this proposal, and that nothing currently keeps the BID from supporting “better restaurants” in the neighborhood.

Stetzer held her ground, though, and pushed for the collaboration. Painting the Partnership as selfless saints, while fawning over its history and “benefit” to the community. She even went further, arguing that the BID is a “quasi-governmental agency” and should have a right to participate in the process.

Bargain district signage, Nov. 2010

For context, the Lower East Side Partnership is a nonprofit whose goal is to support landlords within its commercial district. It was founded in 1991 by local real estate baron Sion Misrahi to attract business to the neighborhood using the “bargain district” slogan. A tidal wave of nightlife ensued. Enough to cause legitimate public heath concerns in the present day, according to one Hunter College study.

The BID also maintains a documented track record of supporting liquor licenses within its district, despite community opposition or bad operators (e.g. The DL, 106 Rivington).

As a post-script, later that evening, Zamsky interrupted the meeting after the committee had moved on to other business and mentioned the alleged hoodwink.

“Stetzer tried to parse that she had not told me that there would not be discussion, but that there wouldn’t be an official presentation,” Zamsky said afterward. “I told her and the committee that I was deeply upset and that this was not true. Stetzer then said that it amounted to nothing, since no official action had been taken. She was then chided by the SLA Committee Chair Alex Militano, who said that we were promised by Coleman at the last meeting that we would be able to attend this one to hear the details. We were then bum-rushed out of the room with more profusely apologetic pleas from Coleman.”

So, again, why does CB3 really want to add the Lower East Side Partnership to the process?

Recent Stories

Entrance to Broadway Lafayette Goes Under the Knife (Again)

One of four main entrances to the Broadway-Lafayette subway station just (partially) closed for an extended period. The shutter, albeit temporary, is the second time for this particular stairwell in the two years since development began at the southwest corner of Lafayette and East Houston. A large sign on the sub-level landing announces the closure […]

An Elon Musk Space on Rivington Street?

Until 106 Rivington Street fulfills its destiny as the next Hell Square nightspot, this. A tunnel construction company? A tipster was out front last night and snapped a few photos before security stepped in. Below a “boring” neon sign, the sparse space is occupied by something called The Boring New York Company. There is a […]

Man Repeatedly Slashed on Rivington Street Yesterday Morning

When someone asks you if you’re a gang member, just keep walking… Early yesterday morning, at around 5am, a man was slashed across the torso near the corner of Rivington and Ridge Streets. Police said that two assailants, male and female, approached another guy and asked if he was a gang member. When the victim […]

My Time Recording the Buzzcocks’ Pete Shelley During his Lower East Side Years

Beloved Buzzcocks frontman Pete Shelley passed away of a suspected heart attack last week (December 6). Ken Lockie, singer-songwriter and sometime collaborator with John (Rotten) Lydon of Public Image Ltd., fondly recalls his time behind the board with Shelley thirty years ago in Williamsburg and on the Lower East Side. Pete Shelley was a charming, likable, […]

Cristin Tierney Gallery Takes Space on the Bowery

The decade-running trend of Chelsea gallery refugees quartering on the Lower East Side continues with news of another. The Cristin Tierney gallery just signed a lease to take over 219 Bowery. It sits one store south of the Camper Lab concept shop, both of which formerly comprised the Chair Up restaurant supplier. Tierney, who had […]