‘Grinch’ Developer Dumped Rotting Garbage, Garden Advocates Allege in $5M Lawsuit

Posted on: September 3rd, 2019 at 5:00 am by

Photo: Children’s Magical Garden

The Children’s Magical Garden last week filed a lawsuit against the owner-developer of the neighboring parcel, accusing him of bullying and harassment. Specifically with regard to the recent dumping of trash into the green space.

The Horizon Group – whose principal, David Marom, acquired the vacant lot from Serge Hoyda in 2013 – has been hell-bent on redeveloping the Garden site into a seven-story luxury building. Only problem is, advocates claimed ownership of his parcel (Lot 19) through adverse possession, and scored an appellate court victory last year that strengthens the argument.

This allegedly hasn’t sat well with Marom, and garden faithful accuse him of ongoing bullying tactics and intimidation, with the sole purpose of making the Garden unusable for community programming, recruiting members, and fulfilling its “philanthropic mission.” His actions ultimately forced the Children’s Magical Garden to file another lawsuit.

The legal action, filed in New York Supreme Court last Wednesday, cites years of “encroachments” by the “vengeful real estate developer,” referring to him as a “grinch.” Most serious being the so-called attack four months ago, in which the accused allegedly broke into the lots and “used power tools to destroy and damage many of the Garden’s treasured plantings, including the empress, mulberry, and maple trees as well as perennial flowers planted on Lots 16 and 18.”

Photo: Children’s Magical Garden

Since 1985, the Children’s Magical Garden functioned on three vacant lots near the corner of Stanton and Norfolk Streets. Two of the three parcels were owned by the city (via HPD), while the third remained private. In May 2013, longtime owner Serge Hoyda acted on plans to construct a six-story building on the land at 157 Norfolk Street (Lot 19), and erected a fence that effectively bisected the greenspace. Two months later, HPD balked under community pressure and bequeathed its parcels (Lots 16 and 18) to the Garden. Hoyda sold his property to the Horizon Group a short time later.

The lawsuit also alleges that, following the April 2019 raid, Marom’s cronies discarded dozens of containers filled with rotting garbage, which were weighed down with water to stymie removal efforts. As a result, the garden apparently became infested with mosquitos, rendering the space unusable for much of the summer.

June 2009

The Garden seeks punitive damages in excess of $5 million.

“We hope this [lawsuit] sends a message to anyone who would leave toxic garbage and harm plants and trees in a children’s garden,” Garden leader Kate Temple-West told us in an email.

Children’s Magical Garden vs. David Marom by BoweryBoogie on Scribd

Recent Stories

I May Survive Coronavirus, but My Friendships Won’t [OP-ED]

While I may survive the COVID-19 pandemic, some of my friendships won’t. As xenophobia grips the masses, racist attacks and harassment against Asians are on the rise at home and abroad. While many would condemn attacks or harassment on social media platforms, how many would intervene when it involves friends? Sadly, my guess is probably not […]

Tenement Museum Faces ‘Extraordinary Crisis’ Amidst COVID-19 Shutdown

The Tenement Museum is struggling to stay afloat, as the COVID-19 shutdown eliminated foot traffic and steady funding. Since closing to the public on March 14, the Lower East Side museum laid off 13 full-time employees (out of 66) – mostly from marketing, visitor services, and gift shop – and told another 40 not to […]

Grindr Date at Baruch Houses Gone Awry as Man Robbed with Taser, Amidst COVID-19 Crisis

A man was threatened with a taser and robbed in the Baruch Houses this week after a Gindr meetup gone awry, police said. The victim had been corresponding with another man on the Grindr dating app, and arranged an early-morning meetup at the Baruch Houses on March 23. (Nevermind, COVID-19.) At 7:30am, the victim arrived […]

Bowery Mission Serving Daily Meals to those in Need, Rain or Shine

While thousands across the city are isolating at home, there are others who don’t have many – if any – options for food or shelter during the Covid-19 pandemic. The Bowery Mission is helping to curtail that by handing out meals to people at their Bowery site. Earlier this week, staff and volunteers distributed “to-go” […]

In Memoriam: Big Steve of East 3rd Street

A fixture on the Lower East Side for decades, Juan “Stevie” Guzman passed away last week of heart complications. He was kind, gentle and hilarious. Affectionately known as “Lil’ Steve,” and later, “Big Stevie,” he and his family lived on East 3rd Street and First Avenue since the 1960s. Many of of his relatives still […]