Mayor Should Call ‘Collect’ for Borough-Based Jail Plan [OP-ED]

Posted on: September 5th, 2019 at 5:09 am by

The Tombs

As expected, the City Planning Commission this week rubber-stamped the controversial jail plan which would see the closure of Rikers Island in favor of four new borough-based jails. Next up is today’s City Council ULURP hearing, which will likely amount to just another mass validation session. Question is, besides the unofficial “common sense” caucus among councilmembers, who else will stand up and speak out against the plan during the open debate? Certainly not Margaret Chin, who has yet to reply to Chinatown leaders’ request for her official stance. So much so that Chinese press recently labeled her, “The offender of the century against Chinatown.”

Over the past few months, Mayor de Blasio’s office has fast-tracked the prison plan, despite community opposition, and often with questionable means. Such as the apparent bait-and-switch on the Environmental Impact Statement from 80 Centre Street to 125 White Street, where the administration is hell-bent on building a Tombs replacement.

Yet, why not look again at alternative locations that may be suitable? Why not Collect Pond Park?

Collect Pond served as the freshwater source for lower Manhattan settlers in the 1700s. It was also a recreational area, albeit briefly. The sixty-foot-deep pond fell on hard times thanks to polluted runoff from the nearby tanneries and slaughterhouses that dotted what is now Mulberry Street. In the early 1800s, the city sealed Collect Pond, and created a canal to help drain the water towards the Hudson River; this canal was itself covered and later became Canal Street.

The city constructed housing atop the capped Collect Pond, yielding the notorious Five Points neighborhood of yore; then present-day Chinatown. The original “Tombs” arrived in 1838, and for the next hundred years, the site was synonymous with jails. The detention center was demolished in 1901, and a replacement “Tombs” followed using concrete caissons going as deep as 140 feet below ground for stability. The current compound across the street at 125 White debuted in 1941.

So, why has Mayor de Blasio and his team dismissed the Collect Pond land as a viable alternate site for the new Chinatown prison? An under-utilized park surrounded by four huge government buildings would seem an ideal location if they must build. The Family Court to its west, Department of Health on the south, criminal courts to the east and 111 Centre Street to the north, these buildings would offer sufficient buffering between residential buildings and the construction site. Access roads for construction and supply vehicles on Lafayette and Centre are also much wider than Baxter. Underground passageways, meanwhile, could provide access to both criminal courts.

Perhaps Collect Pond wasn’t considered due to the underground water source, but given today’s engineering technology it would be totally possible. After all, the city constructed a massive building there a century ago. And architects implemented a “bathtub” foundation for the World Trade Center over 50 years ago to keep water out.

The city has a chance to do right by all involved and lessen the disruption to the surrounding community instead of taking a non-negotiable posture. The Manhattan plan could be revised for a smaller jail in Collect Pond along with renovation of the current Manhattan Detention Complex to accommodate the 1,500 detainee population target.

Recent Stories

Ludlow House Expansion Proceeds with New Building Permits

More movement on the Ludlow House expansion, which is still proceeding rather slowly. Libation closed its doors forever in May of this year. Demise of the bridge-and-tunnel club was hastened by Ludlow House next door, which aims to redevelop the property into a venue annex. (They are leasing the property.) The plan is more than […]

Cops Arrest Bronx Perv for Sexual Assault of 82-Year-Old Woman in Rutgers Houses

Cops arrested a Bronx man on Friday in connection with the sexual assault of an 82-year-old woman in Rutgers Houses. Mott Haven resident, David Alexander, 29, currently faces charges of felony assault, burglary, sexual abuse and restriction of breathing. He’s accused of walking into the victim’s unlocked apartment at about 6pm last Tuesday. Alexander allegedly […]

Boulton & Watt Team Readies ‘Little Ricky’s’ on Ludlow Street

At the corner of Ludlow and Rivington Streets, change is nigh. No, not Beastie Boys Square, but the replacement of a fallen nightlife empire. That of Rob Shamlian. His Grunhaus reboot of Spitzer’s Corner failed to succeed, and closed last spring. In its place, the prolific team behind Boulton & Watt and Drexler’s – Darin […]

Bowery Boogie Uncapped Presents the Golden Gauntlet Graffiti Battle

Hold on to your hats, kids. It’s all out war on the Bowery! Have you ever wanted to see two graffiti writers battle live? Sure you do! I mean, many of us don’t know what we want until we hear about on the interweb, so you’re welcome. Tomorrow night, PACE SSB and REE MTA will […]

Six-Story Row House Replacement Tops out on Grand Street

At the corner of Essex and Grand Streets, two hundred years of history are officially erased. This six-story building – luxury condos – is the future. The drama here is more than four years in the making. After purchasing 355 Grand Street for $4 million in December 2014, Interboro Properties spent the next two years […]