ZARA’s 2nd Floor Becomes Ground Zero for SoHo Rezoning Debate

Posted on: February 5th, 2020 at 5:01 am by

Photo: Eddie Panta

David Thall, a resident who lives directly behind ZARA on Mercer Street, testified that the mall store is scaring off boutique retailers lining Mercer Street. Thall explained that more than four storefronts are currently vacant and that Max Mara vacated his building in large part of because of ZARA. (Boogie confirmed that there are indeed four vacant storefronts on Mercer Street directly behind the block-through Zara building.)

Despite detailed testimony and a lengthy ULURP, the hearing ended without a vote or decisive measure from City Council.  And the future of the SoHo/NoHo Report remains equally ambiguous. Roundly criticized as too vague, advocates and critics of the special permit application continue to find language in the Report that supports their position. For now, the legality of ZARA’s second floor appears stalled in a political conundrum where city officials charged with special permitting are also the sponsors of a community-led zoning study.

But in the end, it was ZARA itself that may have inadvertently provided the best case to deny the application. Lead counsel testified that the City never contemplated the M1-5B zoning restrictions for “mixed-used areas” like Broadway in SoHo, and that the real intention was to prevent the construction of malls in manufacturing areas surrounding the suburbs of the city. But now, as SoHo finds itself “mallified,” these comments actually expressed the desire of community activists, residents and many retailers to maintain some measure of the current zoning rules to prevent any further suburbanization of the City.

This story has multiple pages:

Recent Stories

Astor Place Hair Saved by Deep Pocketed Investors, Including its Landlord

Astor Place Hair was all set to close this week, concluding an impressive seven-decade run. The pandemic reduced customers and business plummeted. Thanks to an eleventh-hour cash infusion, though, the barbershop will stay put. Indeed, news broke yesterday that a conglomerate of investors joined forces to raise the necessary capital. The group includes financier Jonathan […]

Eight Years After Extell, Still No Supermarket for Two Bridges

With One Manhattan Square an eyesore of the Lower East Side skyline for so long, it’s almost impossible to remember what came before. Almost. Indeed, it’s been eight years since Pathmark officially closed its doors, leaving the surrounding Two Bridges community bereft of an affordable supermarket. For much of the local population, a walk to […]

Live Music from the ‘Fiore Escape’ on Essex Street

Lower East Side resident, and COVID-19 survivor, Jill Fiore, continued the Fiore Escape concert concept with a second show on her Essex Street fire escape. Fiore spent this past Saturday evening performing from the second-floor fire escape of her walkup (above Delancey Car Service). It was the second such performance – behind the show on […]

Metro Acres Supermarket Finally Makes its Mark on Clinton Street

The transition is complete. More than a year into its tenancy at 175 Clinton Street, Metro Acres is now at home. In other words, store signage is finally in place, with nary a sign of Fine Fare. The changeover had been gradual since Metro took over, to say the least. First with repositioning (and upscaling) […]

Zazzy’s Pizza Soft Launches in the Old Home of Rosario’s

With Rosario’s Pizza now a proverbial footnote, its successor is now in play. Zazzy’s Pizza is now serving on Orchard Street, albeit in soft launch mode for the last couple weeks. For starters, the health-conscious pizzeria (there are plant-based vegan options) is open for dinner service, 5pm-10pm daily. The takeout window at 173 Orchard is […]