Judge Denies City’s Motion to Dismiss Community Lawsuit in SoHo/NoHo Rezoning

Posted on: June 9th, 2021 at 5:02 am by

Photo: Eddie Panta

The New York State Supreme Court last week denied the city’s motion to dismiss the ongoing community lawsuit over the controversial SoHo/NoHo Rezoning plan. Apparently, the city’s handling of the public review portion of the procedure was cause for concern.

As previously reported, SoHo Alliance and Broadway Residents Coalition together sued the city in April, alleging that the mayor exploited the pandemic to rush through the plan, and deny in-person meetings. Indeed, this central claim was based on the requirement that the Department of City Planning must give the local community board and borough president a detailed summary of any rezoning proposal at least thirty days ahead of the land-use review process and must publish that summary publicly.

Instead, City Planning in April emailed CB2 an announcement that a plan to rezone the two neighborhoods would commence in thirty days.

The claimants’ attorney argued, since insufficient notice was given, that the city must follow the law and submit a detailed summary of its rezoning proposal, and then restart the public review process. The city’s counsel, however, claimed that the manner in which the agency prepared its notice was “discretionary.”

Justice Arthur Engoron appeared to side with the community position, stating that to provide sufficient notice is indeed a requirement and not discretionary. Twice during proceedings he noted that insufficient notice is the same as no notice. Engoron also stated that it would be counterproductive for the city to proceed with the public review process while this case remains active.

The next court date is July 7.

Recent Stories

Cactus Store Resumes Summertime Residency on Essex Street

The Cactus Store returned to the Lower East Side this weekend for its fourth seasonal outing, and first since coronavirus ruined everything. As before, the succulents sellers plant annual roots in the lot at 5 Essex Street. Infrastructure from prior years remains in place. Saturday was opening day. The Cactus Store is a product of […]

Ludlow Street Pizzeria Hits the Open Market

La Margarita Pizza might not have much time left in Hell Square. The Ludlow Street pizzeria is now pitched on the open market. The 800 square-foot store at 268 Ludlow appeared on Craigslist in late-May for $9,000 per month in rent. The listing caps some eight years in business for the Lower East Side pizza […]

Everynight Charley Checkup: Vilray at Rockwood Music Hall

What follows is the beginning of a periodic checkup of the downtown music scene with Everynight Charley Crespo, prolific Editor of The Manhattan Beat. The vocalist, guitarist and songwriter known simply as Vilray (pronounced vill-ree) has an uncanny ability to bridge past and present. Vilray, who does not use his family name, was raised in […]

Mictlan Mexico Brings Orchard Street South of the Border

There is a new taqueria on the Lower East Side. Natalin Perez, who currently operates Haab out in Brooklyn, just lifted the curtains on her new project. The fifteen-table restaurant at 17 Orchard Street, Mictlan Mexico. It takes the reins from the Fat Radish, which spent ten years serving the neighborhood before the pandemic chased […]

The Menace of Summertime Saturday Night on Ludlow Street

With comfort levels of close-quarters partying seemingly back to pre-pandemic norms, Hell Square has rebounded in kind. Neighbors report that any quality-of-life progress gained in this sixteen square-block sector over the last few years completely evaporated. The hordes of hellraisers were out in full force again this past Saturday night. One week after a roving […]